Showing posts with label family. Show all posts
Showing posts with label family. Show all posts

Saturday, March 28, 2020

The Wizard of Oz (1939) - What makes the muskrat guard his musk?


It's the Letterboxd Season Challenge!  Theme nine, part two - a film named a 20th century milestone in cinematography by the American Society of Cinematographers!

(Chosen by John!)

Fellas, fellets, all in-between, let me tell y'all somethin' - it's tough out there sometimes.  Some weeks you wind up emotionally exhausting yourself for multiple days over a lot of trivial here and there, and just don't have it in you to go through the usual motions, like writing out a detailed review for one of the greatest films ever made, even if it's one you personally love to pieces across every aspect.  I've burned myself out well and good here, but I'm still looking to provide y'all with at least a little decent content at a pace of once a week anyhow.  Fortunately, since we're looking at The Wizard of Oz, I've already got a review in my back pocket from when I first watched it at a TCM Live event in January of last year for another challenge!

Having reread my work and slept on it, I still largely agree with what I wrote, and feel I don't have any lengthy new insight a scant year later anyhow.  As such, after a few brief bullet pointed thoughts that'll probably flit between stray observations and jokes, I'll present you with my full review of Dorothy's adventures, and see you on the flipside for when we start the cinéma vérité leg of this journey with High School.  Hope you lot have a decent time staving off the coronavirus, and just remember what Charles Manson said about reruns on Family Guy: "If I haven't seen it, it's new to me!"


  • We can all agree the ASC likely chose this film as one of the 20th century's great achievements in cinematography due to its stunning, popularizing use of Technicolor to make audiences believe in the Land of Oz like no cinematic fantasyland prior.  I'll definitely agree with this, but think it worth noting how Harold Rosson's camerawork goes the extra mile to sell Oz and its tangibility in much the same way his work on the titular musical number from Singin' in the Rain.  The sets on the MGM lot are quite obviously sets, with visibly painted walls and plainly fake plants and all the trappings of reality achieved via paint and wood and fabric, yet the camera tracks a course through these spaces in such a way as to make them feel all the more vast and expansive than they already are.  It'll pan through Munchkinland or seamlessly take us through multiple sets to create the impression of a longer Yellow  Brick Road or position the character skipping towards a flat horizon, and by this movement and emphasis on space make it all feel as if it really does go on forever.  Regardless of how obvious the seams are, your brain honestly believes this is how Oz should be because the camera is so free to explore and convince you there's forever more to be seen.
  • I only briefly mention her below, and I haven't much to add others haven't noted in the preceding century, but Margaret Hamilton's performance as the Wicked Witch of the West really is one of the all-time greats, huh?  The cackle, the hunched, stalking movement, the obvious sense of enjoyment and frustration with every action, the energized presence of an actress who'd reprise the role many times over across the next fifty years out of simple love for the part.  Imagine anyone else doing half so well.  I can't.
  • There's so much to unpack from the line, "Only bad witches are evil," that the world needed to craft an entire multimedia empire with one of the most popular live stageshows ever produced at the center just to explore all the implications.
  • You'd think the Tin Man would be a terrible choice for putting out a fire, considering how oily he is at all times.
  • I've said it before and I'll say it again - I earnestly believe films with this style and approach to effectswork, not just the hoary old "We should ditch CGI and go back to practical effects!" argument, but a total embrace of taking the conventions of stage plays and giving them the best polish studio money can buy can still have a place in the modern cinematic landscape.  Please, anyone, I beg you, give me more soundstage reality productions, they're too glorious and dear to my heart to believe audiences wouldn't respond well anymore.
  • Much as it is fun to joke about movies and throw up a cynical affect at times, I really can't be insincere about this film.  Although I didn't note it in the review below, at the time I told Adept how the Munchkin Land sequence felt distinctly of its time and difficult to appreciate on its own terms, and how the Cowardly Lion's "King of the Forest" song felt like weird filler to keep the film moving rather than a fully realized work on its own terms.  These were my only complaints after my first watch, and on a second I cannot possibly imagine what I was talking about.  They're both delightful segments in a film bursting with delight and charm and whimsy and life, and I can only think I meant they felt the least of a work where everything is at the top of its game and endlessly timeless.  I watched both with the biggest of smiles alongside everything else this time, and as such feel no qualms about bumping what was initially a 4.5 star review up to a perfect 5.  It's just... so terribly good, I haven't words, aside from what I'm about to repeat.
So!

***

To dive right into the heart of the matter, The Wizard of Oz succeeded as a piece of family fantasy entertainment and entrenched itself as THE definitive vision for fantasies in live action until George Lucas upended the game some forty years later entirely because it fails to deliver its moral. Owing to the producers fearing audiences were too sophisticated to believe in Oz as a real place one might escape to, the film ends with the revelation that Dorothy merely dreamt the land of scarecrows and tin men and lions and witches, the parts of her closest allies and greatest enemy having been played by people from her average, everyday life. To give the producers some credit (as if their role in overseeing one of the greatest achievements in factory filmmaking wasn't already credit enough), it's a good decision, as it helps emphasize and transform the book's original standard fantasy adventure ending of "It's so good to be home again" into the more basally resonant, ever-iconic "There's no place like home!" which is a solid moral for a children's story. The visual stylings include little touches emphasizing the idea of comings and goings, and Dorothy's departure from Oz becomes a strong bittersweet moment when we realize the spirit of these lovable characters lives on in their real world counterparts, if not the exact forms we grew to adore.

But it is an utter failure nonetheless. The Wizard of Oz boasts larger than life, blisteringly colorful reality by way of a soundstage fantasy, the sort where you can't help but believe this is EXACTLY the way the Land of Oz should look, even if you can pinpoint the spot where set dressing turns into painted wall at all times. It has some of turn-of-the-century's most beloved children's literary characters realized through still-technically-impressive makeup and soft, charming performances from up-and-comers and vaudeville staples alike. It moves at a great clip, has little touches of comedy at every turn (I was just... so glad to hear the reactions of people who've obviously loved this film for decades and still get the fullest enjoyment out of it in the theater today), and a sentimental approach to every aspect of the production so strong that you can easily forget how brutal studio work could get eighty years back. It has the "If I Only Had A..." songs, and "Ding-Dong the Witch Is Dead!", and "We're Off To See the Wizard", and "Somewhere Over the Rainbow", for chrissake.

You can't make a movie with "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" and not have people believe it. Bringing a fantasy world to life and then telling your audience they should really be grateful for their warm bed and loved ones is always a hard sell, because you simply cannot spend so much money making the fantasy world look the way it does and expect home to look even half so attractive. In the case of Oz, Mervin LeRoy and Victor Flemming and the veritable army of MGM staffers responsible for this world did such a good job making its scenery and inhabitants feel real and immediate, the decision to deny their reality at the end comes across as little more than an attempt to avoid stepping on the toes of a far more conservative America.

Thank God the film fails. If it were to sell you on the notion of Oz as a nice fantasy, but ultimately less preferable than life on the Kansas farm, it would require a far inferior Oz. Perhaps a less menacing Wicked Witch, or a less lush Munchkin Land, or a less joyous Emerald City, or - heaven forbid! - a less endearing Cowardly Lion. Something would have to go wrong for Kansas to ring true as the best of all worlds, and then where would we be? In a time where the film doesn't continue to birth homages and inspirations for how to make the impossible believable? When its themes didn't resonate so powerfully in the wakes of both the Great Depression on original release and World War II on rerelease as to serve as a comforting delight for children the world over? When audiences would ever want to do anything but hug the Cowardly Lion and never leave him behind because he's perfect just the way he is?

No, it's better that The Wizard of Oz fails to convince the audience of a healthier moral. Such pure, unbridled fantasy took near-inhuman levels of personal sacrifice and compromise to bring to the screen. We almost saw a classic encapsulation of the studio system in its prime and the American willingness to accept flying monkeys and fraudulent wizards changed into something totally unrecognizable a million times over in the development process. A film like this is, after its own fashion, a miracle, and should a miracle stumble over its words while trying to instruct us on loving our home more than a land over the rainbow, then why not take advantage of its failure to communicate and live there for a while? Happy little bluebirds fly - why, then, oh why can't we?

5/5

Friday, October 25, 2019

Halloweentown (1998) - See you in the afterlife!


Depending on how you contextualize the matter, the Disney Channel film Halloweentown is either a standard tween drama about asserting your independence with a thin layer of watered-down spooky imagery slathered on top, or a standard kitchen sink fantasy family romp with a thin layer of watered-down tween drama sprinkled about.  Neither characterization does the production any favors, implying nothing particularly special about the base story while making the flavoring sound unappealing and insufficient.  Although you'd have to press me fairly hard to get me confessing I feel any different than this, I think it about as fair to have a go at Halloweentown for what it is as I do for all the films highlighted in this marathon - which is to say, not fair in the slightest.  Why take the movie to task for trying to give kids a safe, enjoyable entrypoint into spoopy material and SLIGHTLY more complicated family dynamics than they'd be otherwise used to when its legacy as a nostalgic classic indicates it landed just right with its target audience?  There's more than plenty failures inherent to the film's construction to use as fuel for a nice coal-raking beyond its conception, after all!

I more than understand the limitations imposed on a project of this nature.  Child labor laws dictate children can't work outside certain hours, so location shoots need to take place during the day and night scenes can't take advantage of natural dark.  Filming permits are expensive, as are props and costumes, and the challenges of set dressing grow exponentially when trying to transform a real location.  Interiors, though less logistically challenging, still constitute a real expense, and the overall company bottom line will come out healthier if old sets are recycled with minimal changes.  Costumes and special effects eat into a budget like nobody's business; cheaper alternatives to the cutting edge and a lack of make-up or prosthetics on the leads make an acceptable cost cutting measure.  And we mustn't forget how all of this is done on a TV budget, with a TV production cycle, and a particular target date to hit due to the holiday theming of the picture.  Movies are stupid hard to make, and the people behind them deserve no grief for the multiple reasonable compromises necessary to turn in a project on time and in budget.

From an end-viewer's experience, though, it's still hard to lose the feeling of Halloweentown as a disappointing setting.  A magical world full of all the monsters and creatures and beings you associate with All Hallow's Eve, realized as a tiny town square with minimal set dressing beyond the big stone jack-o-lantern prop.  The interiors we visit could readily double for homes and ice cream parlors and saunas (???) in any Disney Channel production save the inhabitants, who wander about in costuming ranging from passable to obviously inflexible latex.  Exterior shots not only rarely leave the tight confines of the town square, they rarely leave one side of the street.  Everything about this wondrous fantasy land wherein main character Marnie Cromwell's dreams of becoming a witch feels tiny, dingy, and uninspired, hardly what you want from a children's film trying to sell the magic of a town where it's Halloween every day.  I put no blame on the crew or schedule masters for doing their best under doubtlessly cramped, underfunded circumstances, but I do put blame on director Duwayne Dunham for not allocating screen resources better.  When compared against the potential of the setting to capture the eye through the whole runtime, I hardly think the puppetry needed to animate a skeleton taxi driver for a handful of scenes a worthwhile choice.

Mark you, for much Halloweentown, I can only tell what the town looks like by squinting at the frame's margins.  For reasons I cannot comprehend, practically every dialogue sequence is shot in extreme close-up, with characters' faces completely dominating the picture.  Not a medium or wide in sight any time people are talking, regardless of whether the location or action around them would benefit from a slightly pulled-back lens.  It's as if the whole movie was shot with the camera parked inches from the actors' faces, which makes for quite the miracle when considering how even the youngest child actor only occasionally acknowledges its presence.  Staying so needlessly, uncomfortably close makes the already fairly charmless town feel even more drab and uninviting, because the unexciting image of not-so-great child actors badly emoting as they half-scream through their lines lingers in the brain far more readily than that of a supposedly wondrous setting.  At the very least, it's preferable to be pressed up against the kid characters' faces, seeing as they're not half so creepy as Robing Thomas' damn-near pedophilic Kalabar getting up in our business.  He's thankfully not in this much, though his scenery chewing delivery towards the end is also afforded no flattery by the overly close camera.

With regards to those kids, I could certainly do with less of them.  Not regarding the snarky, self-satisfied dialogue, something endemic to practically all family friendly children's media in the 90s.  Not regarding Kimberly J Brown's Marnie, who's only bland and uninteresting in the mold of pretty much all protagonists of this nature.  Certainly not with regards to Emily Roeske's Sophie, an actually endearing presence in the film and one I wish had more to do than repeat the same three lines of dialogue over and over again when the scene's not totally focused on her, even if it's just doing some more unique cute things.  With regards to Joey Zimmerman as Dylan, the smug, brainy, "rational" brat brother of the bunch.  Him being eight years my senior and fully grown nowadays, I feel no qualms in stating I absolutely cannot stand the kid - not the way he's written, not the way he's dressed, not the way he delivers his lines, not the immaturity he inspires in anyone who responds to him, not the basic conception of his character as a skeptic who has to actively call out everything around him as fake before adopting a forced cheery "everything's obviously a dream so I'll roll with it, you freak dream people" attitude, none of it.  He's a prominent presence throughout the whole film, getting at least one grating line per scene, and the screenplay's idea of allowing him development is to grant him magic powers and then immediately slide back into the same viewpoint as always.  The whole "believe in yourself and love your family and you can do anything" message is fair and fine for a film of this nature, but it stands on shaky ground when the person two inches to the left of the main character going through all this self-improvement journey stuff is talking smack at it every step of the way and seemingly learns nothing by the time the last frame fades.  He's awful, and I actively wish he wasn't in the movie, particularly because he reminds me of myself at his age, and I don't think any child needs exposure to that blither.

Halloweentown probably ain't worth all this, as I mentioned up top, much as it's plainly a cheapie attempt to cash in on Tim Burton providing Disney a marketable name and concept in The Nightmare Before Christmas.  It's a Disney Channel movie from two decades ago, fer chrissake.  All the stuff I've mentioned is bad, but not "all those paragraphs what I wrote up there" bad, and on the whole it's an inoffensive runaround without anything special to its name.  Fact of the matter is, there's Homestuck nonsense going today, I get nice and riled up by the thought of Andre Hustle continuing to desecrate the corpse of something that WAS special and meaningful to me, I need a punching bag which doesn't come with painful memories of past fights and undue emotional turmoil, and Halloweentown makes the perfect target.  So take that, you nothing of a Disney Channel movie.  Bear the brunt of my negative energy, so I might feel better while watching and analyzing Van Gogh tonight.

There are multiple elements at play here to indicate the separate dimension Halloweentown exists within is actually hell, and I don't feel kind enough to the film to think of alternate interpretations for any of them.  Benny the skeleton cab driver is slowly roasting for the sins he committed in life, and he probably deserves it.

2.5/5