Showing posts with label mixed nutcrackers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mixed nutcrackers. Show all posts

Saturday, December 28, 2019

Mixed Nutcrackers Wrap-Up!

Heads up: sometime in the next few days, I intend to write some wrap-up posts for the Cult, Comedy, and Queer challenges I run on letterboxd, as a means of introducing such content to the site and prepping for the next year of featuring them more heavily on this space.  For these, I'll probably provide a top ten best and top ten worst from each challenge (perhaps less for the Queer challenge, just because there's fewer films than in the other two, and they never got quite so bad as the others), alongside any stray observations about other notable films or ideas we encountered in the last year's watching.  This post... will not be like that!  While I could easily handle it like I did the wrap-up for the Loft Film Fest and rank all the films in contention, there's not much fun there - I've already given the full extent of my thoughts on everything here, and the rankings seem fairly obvious.  Here, I can burn through em right now:

1: Fantasia (5/5)
2: The Nutcracker 1973 (4/5)
3: Nutcracker Fantasy (3.5/5)
4: Nutcracker: The Motion Picture (3.5/5)
5: The Nutcracker at the Bolshoi Ballet (No rating)
6: Barbie in the Nutcracker (3/5)
7: The Nutcracker 1990 (3/5)
8: The Nutcracker Prince (2.5/5)
9: The Nutcracker and the Four Realms (2/5)
10: The Nutcracker in 3D (2/5)
11: Tom and Jerry: A Nutcracker Tail (2/5)

Fun-ish.  But I believe we can have yet more fun than this!  I believe there are elements to these Nutcracker tales deserving their own ranking, separate from that of the pictures as a whole.  As such, we are going to rank...

The Nutcrackers!

(With respect to both their animate Nutcracker forms, their real human forms, their inanimate forms where applicable, and overall personality!  Obviously Fantasia won't partake in these events, but it has won enough by being wonderful as it is already.)


Friday, December 27, 2019

Mixed Nutcrackers: Fantasia (1940)


Call this a belated Christmas present. After a solid month of delaying season challenge stuff so we could wade through ten different Nutcracker adaptations of varying quality, we come to Fantasia, a film wholly divorced from the rest of the marathon save its use of Tchaikovsky's music in one segment, and to pull a quote from Deems Taylor, this is all to the good. Strip away the decades of filmic evolution that led Disney so far astray as to make something so uninspired and wretched as The Nutcracker and the Four Realms, roll back the years of artistic waxing and waning, settle on down for an older form of animated experimentation, and you find Fantasia, the single most diamond perfect film Walt Disney ever produced. I am tired from spending so much time plowing through Mixed Nutcrackers this last month, and from spending so much time over this last year watching and writing about so many movies, so I am going to simply extend the Christmas gift of watching Fantasia to gushing about its varied virtues in a series of bullet points. There will, as per usual, likely turn into more full-blown paragraphs, only justified as bullet points by the lack of structural linkage between each. It's my present to me, though, so we do things how I like.

  • The flow of Toccata and Fugue in D Minor hypnotizes me anew with each watch. Credit some of the effect to Deems Taylor's introductory statements, which put one in the proper frame of mind for interpreting the abstract imagery on display, but the actual lulling spell of the images on their own tell quite the story as well. From simply playing with angled colored lights on Leopold Stokowski as he conducts facing away from the audience, to filling the screen with massive fragmenting shadows of the orchestra's sections, to the abstract interpretation of musical notes floating in space as your mind drifts away from the physical and into the purely artistic. The little blue plunking ripple dots playing through the hair to represent fingers covering holes on a woodwind are always a favorite, as are the slightly jagged wavering yellow lines dancing in a stutterstep one after the other across the sky for the strings. When the piece moves beyond awareness of even the instruments and gets into simple phantasmagorical landscapes conjured by sound alone, those rolling pink-and-black-striped hills alongside the constant return to a rolling river of red akin to volcanic flows always leave one floored by how smooth and utterly natural they look for something done entirely by hand. Ending the segment on a return to Stokowski, at first a small figure conducting a brilliant sunrise before we zoom in to find him commanding little more than a glaring, solid block of red, makes the perfect scene-setter for the rest of Fantasia. We're here to watch a dance between sound and vision, overseen by a massive crew so powerful and firm a guiding hand that it looks as if a single figure instructs its complexities by magic, and it is beautiful.
  • Of all the pieces in Fantasia, the Nutcracker Suite sounds most different from its traditional interpretation - most other pieces undergo some form of rearrangement to suit the story flow, but where the Rite of Spring and the Pastoral Symphony mostly resemble the conventional choices in modern, standardized orchestration, and Night on Bald Mountain practically set the piece's standard sound, the Nutcracker Suite was a solid decade and change out from its reinvention and revitalization in the New York ballet. As such, the instrumentation on many of its movements isn't quite what you've come to expect from their use as Christmas staples in prior decades. The Russian Dance, for instance, features reedier sounding strings and a heavier emphasis on percussion than the newer variations, while the Sugarplum Fairy Dance has a gentler, slightly eerier vibe than the more familiar crystalline, ringing interpretation. With how omnipresent many of these pieces are in the broader popular culture (and even how familiar pieces like the Arabic Dance are to the ballet community), the deviating musical choices here help make Fantasia's version of Tchaikovsky's music fall upon fresh ears every time, exactly as radical visual reinterpretations like this should.
  • Disney's animation department was really well truly at the top of their game in 1940, right? The sparkling play of dewdrops across multiplane background elements and spider's silk as fairies prepare a garden for the dawn, the elegant, flowing gossamer on the fish fins as they whirl in an underwater dance, the beautiful skipping dance of flower petals and leaves on the wind in time with the music without feeling like they're doing anything other than following a natural current upon the air, the way palpably chilly patterns of ice appears at the fairies' feet when they skate across the water as individually designed snowflakes drift down from the sky? Not to mention working multiple approaches to humanizing the non-human, from the elongated lithe torsos on the fairies, to the fish with little more than solid heads attached to practically strips of fabric, to the two wholly different modes of making anthropomorphized flowers dance between the Russian Dance and Waltz of Reed Flutes that are equally suited to the flying leaps and spinning grace of both pieces, to the unfortunate but still adorable mushrooms pitter-pattering about during the Chinese Dance? I love looking at this segment so much, and have to wonder what if Walt's ambitions came to fruition, what if we really did see animation take a turn towards Fantasia's ambitions in the following decades, without the war and the strike and the public disinterest? It's a massive shame more works at this level never came to be, even if it does leave Fantasia feeling wholly unique.
  • If Mickey Mouse is gonna hang about the movie, he might as well hang about in the best-looking Mickey Mouse short ever drawn, yeah? The Sorcerer's Apprentice is a little bit unusual for Fantasia, considering it's the only segment to function like a morality play, what with Mickey skiving off his master's discipline-building task to take the easy route of enchanting a broom to carry the water for him, and finding his efforts arrested by an inability to stop what he's started. It still works well as part of the whole, though, entirely because it ALSO functions as a chance for the animation team to show off how good they'd gotten at character animation on their flagship face, how the water effects in Pinnochio weren't merely a one-off fluke, how they could take something so simple and silly as a broom with arms and transform it into a series of arresting images by multiplying the thing and sending it on a shadow-heavy unstoppable march. The additional minor fun of playing with smoke to form bats and butterflies, the shooting stars in Mickey's dream, and Bill Tytla showing off by animating the only realistically-proportioned human in the film with some of its most subtly expressive movements enhances the fun all the more. This isn't really Mickey's movie, but he advances the project's ambitions so much by showing how a simple Mickey Mouse cartoon, once the realm of light entertainment for the real show, can stand as a legitimately artistic, lovingly-crafted work alongside the more immediately art-like pieces before and after.
  • I'm legitimately joke angry about the galaxy that starts The Rite of Spring. Just... look the thing up sometime, find a copy of Fantasia and LOOK at it. The thing's an equal to any galaxy you see animated by computers for bottom-of-the-barrel programs on the Science Channel nowadays, and they did it by HAND. S'enough to make a full-grown person cry at its beauty and the skill necessary to get it twinkling and rotating like that. Makes the sorta wonky sun we see a few seconds later all the funnier lookin', tho.
  • While the creature design in The Rite of Spring is hopelessly outdated by modern palentological standards, it holds infinite charm for me all the same. Contrast between the natural elegance of lava bubbling and flowing and tearing the earth asunder, and the pencil sketch-like early single cell organisms in the Cambrian seas make the slow march towards complex life highly satisfying to watch, particularly once we make the leap to the dinosaurs and see the sheer diversity on offer. They're quite unlike anything in the Disney style without deviating so much as to be unrecognizable as something from their house, and whether we're considering the swooping pteranodons, the massively bulky stegosauri, or the monstrous early vision of a T-rex, each offers some insight into how the late 1930s' understanding of fossil records mingled in conversation with an artist's impulse for what's most striking and memorable. I'd love to see someone, anyone, Bogleech, run a retrospective on all the designs on display here, and how they stack up to what we know now. Even if many of the ideas are a little bit silly (there's a jellyfish using its tentacles to snare a fish and chew with its membrane), an article to this effect would delight me to an equal extent as the segment itself.
  • I don't know why, but I've always liked the effect of rendering one of the brontosaurs in a panning shot as primarily painted background element for the main body, with an animated neck and head stretching out into the distance. Gets across depth in the shot quite well, and I notice it in particular every single time I watch Fantasia.
  • Leave it to Disney's Golden Age animator stable to construct a memorable, charming character from nothing but pleasing abstract shapes and pitch-perfect timing. The part where Taylor interviews the soundtrack and coaxes the simple vertical line to demonstrate its potential by vibrating in time to different instruments is an easy highlight. The fat, jiggly slabs meant to represent a bassoon's lowest notes are the absolute best, though the cheeky little triangle ting at the end of the percussion section and the wild flare they put into animating the brass make solid contenders for the title. Its little jig to the right before sliding off-screen also pleases one to no end.
  • Confession time: While Fantasia is very much the perfect movie, and while I will fight anyone who says otherwise verbally and physically, the Pastoral Symphony is always where I start to fidget in my seat just a little bit, and check the time remaining where the previous segments kept me wholly engaged and enraptured. This, I think, comes more down to my own issues with sitting still and focusing for extended periods of time than any fault of Fantasia's, for the Pastoral Symphony's vision of Grecian mythology is still a wondrous thing to look at, all gentle pastels and soft character designs and gentleness right up until Zeus shows up for a little bit of what Zeus does second best. The pegasi look majestic, their children adorable, the centaur's appropriately suave and dopey, that little romance between the blue centaurs gets me right there in the chest, the 40s Disney vision of Dionysus is about as perfect as you can get, and I am once again made angry by how lovely Iris' rainbow and the starry Athena shooting a flaming arrow cross the sky look for how much effort it must've taken to get them looking just right. It's mostly just... I don't have much to say regarding overall effect or place in the program here; it's gorgeous and gorgeosity made manifest through paint and paper and celluloid, and I've little more to contribute to the larger conversation than "purdy." Which is fine, cause sometimes a piece of art appeals to you aesthetically for no real deeper reason, and you can love it for what it is on a surface level just as is.
  • If there's one spot where the modern, widely available version of Fantasia legitimately clunks, it's when they have to awkwardly repeat some shots of a centaur strutting and posing for the camera in order to realign the visuals to the music after chopping out a solo shot of Sunflower the Racist Caricature. I'm not at all sure how you could make up for the time difference with any elegance short of biting the bullet and reinstating her for historical purposes, but even without knowing why the repetition happens, one can still tell it's not a natural choice by the original team. 
  • Every time I watch Fantasia, without exception, without fail, The Dance of the Hours starts up, and I expect it to be the place where my opinion lessens and I go, "Well this one part isn't quite so good as the rest." The whole thing's more directly comedic than any of the other segments, basing itself around the joke of performing a ballet with awkwardly shaped animals not at all suited for executing pirouettes or pliés or grand jetés. We're effectively watching a more conventional funny animal cartoon in the midst of a film about to thunder into one of the best animated finales ever put to screen, so the expectation for it to suck the joy out've the room comes wandering in uninvited without fail. And yet, I always enjoy The Dance of the Hours. As a technical achievement it's not quite the equal to those it follows, but it's a damned impressive funny animal cartoon with a wide display of body shapes and weights and impossibilities made feasible thanks to expressive characters, personable sight gags, and a sympathetic environment shifting through times of day across lovely looking color shifts. As a part of Fantasia, it works well for the same reason Mickey's appearance earlier in the film does: Disney built its bones on these funny animal cartoons, so even though they're reaching for higher and higher artistic ambitions with ideals towards the mainstream recognizing animation as a serious technique, they're not gonna forget where they came from. They're gonna elevate the funny animal cartoon by putting all their skills to use for the BEST, most graceful funny animal cartoon they can possibly manage, and I'll be smacked if they didn't produce something with admirable pacing, imaginative twists and turns, and a killer ending with the whole anarchic jumble the finale became capping with a pull back to the palace doors slamming so hard they fall off their hinges. Fantasia leaps my worries about this segment every year, solidifies itself as a favorite by assuring me it displays mastery of every technique it tries, and leaves the air clear for ideal enjoyment of its final part.
  • That Fantasia positions The Dance of the Hours' funny animal cartoon right next to its exploration of the profane and the sacred in Night on Bald Mountain/Ave Maria speaks to Walt Disney's confidence in animation's potential as a high-minded, cultured artform to equal painting or opera. You can explore the medium's most pedestrian, every-day, mass-appeal application to its fullest extent with no shame about laughing at the absurdity of hippos and elephants serving as ballerinas, turn around for a trip into the deepest bowels of hell rising up to manifest themselves upon this sinful earth in a gorgeous and frightening danse macabre, and then depict a pilgrim's journey of the long winding path to find beauty and divinity in the simple act of watching a sunrise, and have it all WORK because you're good at your job and have a vision in your mind, a spark in your eyes, and an army of hands and machines capable of bringing it all to life. Fantasia's last and best segment is so much better for working in conversation with something so simple and pleasing as "the animals they are too ungainly to dance," and illustrates Fantasia's main point better than any other individual part. It's all art, it's all beautiful, it's all worthy of love and care and admiration and immortality and all the other fine descriptive words for something so insightful and perfect. Even that which we might consider lesser deserves appreciation at the same level as the holy.
  • And yeah, even leaving aside how they interact with the movie at large, Night on Bald Mountain/Ave Maria are technical accomplishments beyond compare, in the Disney oeuvre and in the larger animation industry. I've never understood or found sources explaining just what they did to make the ghostly spirits rising from their graves and flying to the mountain peak look the way they do, but it communicates the dead rising to roam the earth better than anything else I've ever seen. Tytla's work on Chernabog is nothing short of masterful, be it his powerful flexing as he unfolds his wings, his sweeping gestures as he summons the damned to his domain, the way his face twists and contorts itself into new expressions in close-up, or the way he becomes a pillar of evil's eternal power in the sequence's final shot before cowering back to inert rock. The maelstrom of hellfire which consumes his followers and sweeps demonic figures across the camera is beautiful as it is terrible. I am all about the way they render Chernabog's exposure to the ringing light of church bells by transitioning his figure from the solid inky blacks to what look like heavy pencil sketch fills and back on each chime. And as to the pilgrims' progress through several Disney's most complex ever multiplane camera shots, well... they inspire one. Inspire one to contemplate the purpose of a disciplined walk, lit candle in hand, face obscured, following a winding path through the damp, dense woods, knowing evil lurks out there somewhere, following the hard trail laid down by ancestors long past, for the purpose of appreciating the effort behind each step, the beauty of the world scantly illuminated by your tiny light as dawn builds all around. The revelation of just how profound the simple sight of clouds drifting through the sky on a sunny morning can be with thoughts of grace in your skull. How all this, how the wild torment of wicked madness and the slow, methodical approach to showing the beauty and specialness in something that happens every day when seen with the right eyes, is directly reflective of the work necessary to make something like Fantasia possible.

God, I love this movie. Can we not talk about any other movies from now on? Can I just keep watching Fantasia once every few weeks, jotting down some new thoughts about something I noticed fresh this time, and forget about all the other bad films out there? I know we can't, for Fantasia wouldn't appear half so special if it didn't have the whole cinematic landscape to tower over as a magnificent, impeccable work of filmmaking, but... I don't wanna come down, man. The whole world seems beautiful as Fantasia from up here. I'll press on as always, cause I won't find new towers to survey the land from and find peace atop, but you won't catch me at all liking it. And we can always return here whenever we like, for the simple pleasure of being and seeing.

5/5

Monday, December 23, 2019

Mixed Nutcrackers: The Nutcracker and the Four Realms (2018)


Over the last month, I've spent quite considerable hunks of time puzzling over why The Nutcracker and the Four Realms exists.  The reasons are quiet obvious and take little time to figure, of course - Disney intersected with Tchaikovsky's work very briefly when they adapted his Nutcracker Suite for a segment in Fantasia, Disney's been on a streak of remaking various classics of theirs both major and minor alike, and 2018's Star Wars offering targeted the traditional May release window rather than their new Christmas block, so turning out a big-budget Nutcracker film like they've been proprietors and overseers of the beloved property all this time works for a holiday market thing.  They don't even have to buy a whole studio to get the rights like they'll have to if they ever want to make coin off The Wizard of Oz, they've just gotta pretend that their all-encompassing dominance over childhood nostalgic properties has a transference effect across anything and everything in the public domain with the tiniest connection to Disney, and voila!  It even makes sense why it is the way it is, for Tim Burton's vile take on Alice in Wonderland made over one billion dollars worldwide, Kenneth Branagh's better Cinderella did respectable business for its budget, and overconfidence in the Disney offices keeps bad ideas afloat even after, say, Alice Through the Looking Glass turned out a financial disappointment.  You've a license to print money with recognizable properties done up in action-fantasy regalia, so away we go, 130 million dollar budget, gonna be a grand ol' time, woo!

My questions were more philosophical in nature.  Why are we here, at this point on the board?  Must it continue on like this?  Is there any conceivable creative spark behind the greenlighting and production of this film, or is it truly just an idea whose final form doesn't matter so long as someone can check off a little box on a list of Good Ideas What Will Make A Billion Dollars?  The answer to all of these questions is yes, without fail, but I wonder all the same.  The trailer and related marketing materials, though over-designed to such a degree as to embody a wonkily admirable aesthetic all their own, simply looked so boilerplate and uninspired in what they implied, it seemed the only reason any of the Nutcracker stuff showed its face was for the purpose of having a little more reason to use the Sugar Plum Fairy dance and Waltz of the Flowers on the soundtrack than normal in a Christmas movie.  And is that really what anyone wants to make a movie about?

Not asking whether the audience wants to SEE it or not, no, I'm curious about the folks who've gotta write and act in and design and direct this stupid thing.  Is this how you wish to spend your twilight years, Morgan Freeman?  Is this how you foresaw your first big mainstream exposure coalescing, Jayden Fowora-Knight?  How exactly did you get here, Lasse Hallström?  Were the ABBA music videos and What's Eating Gilbert Grape and all those dog movies not enough?  Must you architect something with no soul?

Whatever the reasons (for I'll never know), The Nutcracker and the Four Realms exists, and it's about exactly what its trailers make it out as.  New take on Clara Stahlbaum going through a magical adventure in her Godfather Drosselmeyer's house, except instead of a small skirmish between toys and mice with a semi-sweet kinda romance as the main pull, it's this big to do about a locked mechanical egg without a key gifted by her dead mother and a fantasy kingdom the elder Stahlbaum created from crude inert matter with multiple realms based on a few dances from the Tchaikovsky ballet, and wouldn't you just know it the whole thing's gone to hell in a handbasket with a mysterious arch villainand frightening circus imagery and need for a strong warrior queen to march forth and save us all as prophecy foretold and aaaaaaaaaaagh.  Pretty lookin' but vapid to the extreme, and lacking in any real identity of its own - in addition to all the bog-standard "Classic fairytale kingdom from your childhood is a little more Game of Thrones now" trappings, they've pinched bits and bobs from Alice, Oz, Narnia, and Disney's newer animated canon entries with shameless liberty.  The whole concept's a glass-molded, sugar-coated diorama piece, endlessly reflective of its counterparts an tasting of nothing in particular, a bad bedrock for any story to rest upon.

Somehow, with such an easy formula as, "Exposit, adventure, twist, conclude" to follow as inherited from all the other fantasy imitators its imitating, The Nutcracker and the Four Realms manages to back itself into a corner with some impressively bad character writing.  Clara, as played by Mackenzie Foy (who shall remain largely blameless, for not doing anything with the following is probably nobler than making a futile effort), has an alright if simple set of traits at the movie's start: she's clever and into tinkering with machines, she's upset about her mom's death, doesn't want to socialize in the way expected of her societal station, and clashes with her father over how to deal with the grief, retreating into her mechanics as he does his stuffiness.  With the whole thing regarding her mysterious locked egg that no amount of tinkering can open without the key, there's the basis for a bit of self-discovery and growth via the medium of an adventure in bootleg Middle-Earth cum Narnia.  Too bad for us, though, soon as she follows a string into the Four Realms, she becomes little more than an audience surrogate.  All sense of individual personality gets wiped away so she's free to marvel at the pretty sights and wonder at the new characters and feel sad when we're supposed to feel sad and get invested when we're supposed to get invested.  Lacking much identity of her own for a goddamned half-hour effectively distances one from her, and primes you less to fall under this world's magical spell, and more notices how it's so concerned with crunching exposition that it only spares about ten seconds total to show you three of the four realms from the title.

(Seriously, they're probably the best designed locations in the film, and we get a single shot of each.  Rest of the movie's in a comparatively empty - and probably easier to render - golden palace and various sparse dead woods.)

So, follow me on this one, please, I'm about to do a Thing.  Clara has learnt all about the ins and outs of the Four Realms, the supposed dangers posed by Mother Ginger in the disgraced Fourth Realm, and how her mother used a giant machine called The Engine to bring the whole fantasy kingdom to life, effectively making her heir to God's throne in this land.  The three good regents need The Engine to build an army to stand against Mother Ginger or else face extermination, but woe of woes! it's broken!  Now Clara, showing signs of life and personality for the first time in ages, perks up and suggests she might be able to tinker with the machine and solve the problem, because she's really good with machines and finally has someplace where her talents will be appreciated!  But no, we don't actually need her skills or anything unique about her - we need her mother's key, the same key that opens her mechanical egg.  Off a-marching we a-go, having a grand old time running about the Fourth Realm, getting attacked by mice, creeped out by clowns, just sorta doing whatever action-y thing comes to mind to tick off time because this little key hunt is all we have for a second act... long story short, Clara gets the key, opens the egg, and nothing.  She's devastated, because her mother left a note saying everything she needed was right inside the egg, and there's nothing, so clearly there's nothing important or special about her.

Gee gosh willikers, wouldn't you know it, we get back to the palace, turn on the Engine, and the Sugar Plum Fairy's really the villain for reasons that don't matter and I don't really care about.  Point being, she throws Clara in the tower dungeon and plans to destroy the whole Four Realms or something, and Clara?  Clara starts getting ideas in her head.  Clara starts thinking she has to reach deep down inside, find an inner strength she never knew she had, trust in her knowledge of the laws of mechanics, use them to escape and figure out a way to save the day.  She enacts a great escape with lots of verve and daring-do!  She spirits her way back into the throne room, where her mother's Engine is spurting out unstoppable tin soldiers!  And in a grand act of self-actualization, she sneaks up to the machine, and... uses her tinkering skills to shut it down and stop the Sugar Plum Fairy.  Turns out what she needed to do was exactly what she thought she needed to do at the start of the second act, just with an arbitrary march to kill her self-confidence and a little alone time to figure out something about herself she already knew.

That's not a character arc.  That's a character ten-yard penalty.  "Achieved self-actualization too soon, ten yards back, first down."

I don't know.  What else'd'y'want from me here?  The Nutcracker's a complete non-entity with no personality and even less reason for being singled out as important in the movie's shaky lore, the backstory and whole dramatic situation relies on implications from Morgan Freeman and flashbacks to Clara's mother which communicate a wholly different backstory than the one Sugar Plum's heel-turn is predicated on through monologue, and its ten steps backwards ten steps forwards story has nothing to say at the end of the day beyond "Keep visiting your childhood imaginary kingdom, or it'll all burn to ash because you weren't good enough to not grow up!"  I liked the Mouse King's reimagining as a mouse golem comprised of thousands of mice, though far more as a concept than for how he looks or anything he does, some portions of the expository ballet are rather pretty in both physical movement and the practical effects around the dancers, and the soulless tin soldiers are fairly, appropriately creepy.  I'm rather upset at how they only play a few snatches of the final dance piece on a tinny little music box before swapping over to the more "dramatic" sounding Waltz of the Flowers for the real final dance and - does it matter?

Do my further critiques and weak, minor praises have any purpose?  It's not fundamentally broken like the Tom and Jerry outing, and it doesn't fall as far into eye-popping, misguided arrogance as 3D, but unlike those works, I cannot think of how to improve this.  If I intuited some better means of handling Clara's arc (read: making it an arc in the first place), devised a better use of our first act time than uselessly oggling empty spectacles whilst hiding away the ACTUAL production design achievements behind weird editing choices, strained and labored and sweated to scrub out the uncomfortable "child God fantasies must last forever!" implications, it wouldn't be for anything.  The base idea of "The Nutcracker but we're Lord of the Rings and Narnia now" is bad and nonfunctional of itself, and my absolute best suggestion, being "Use a different concept," requires eradicating the movie entire down to its bones to keep suggesting anything better.  Uniquely-shaped failure to write a coherent story for its heroine marks the most remarkable thing about The Nutcracker and the Four Realms, and I'm half-inclined to say we shouldn't imagine a better movie in its place, because a muck-up like this is too rare and special to deny.  Why continue spilling digital ink on a work I've declared poorly conceived from start to finish, and cannot accept the obvious answers over the whys of its existence for how much they shake my faith in an inherently good universe?

Movie's bad.  Don't go watching it.  Check out Nutcracker Fantasy and the 1973 Nutcracker short instead.  They're far more charming, creative, better designed, and free on YouTube as of this writing to boot.  Hell, watch the Barbie movie, it at least does more with its golem character and out-and-back narrative structure.

2/5

Saturday, December 21, 2019

Mixed Nutcrackers - The Nutcracker in 3D (2010)


Goodness, but ambition sure can go wrong, can't it?  Andrei Konchalovsky reportedly sat on and tinkered with the idea for what ultimately became The Nutcracker in 3D (alternately The Nutcracker: The Untold Story) for a solid twenty years, long after he became a frequent film fest circuit contender, and in which time he continued to direct, write, and produce a wide variety of films across multiple genres.  This here was his passion project, a grand fantasy epic built upon little by little whenever he had time, finally realized after two decades' gestation with a budget of $90 million, well in excess of anything he'd directed since Tango and Cash.  Grand ideas given grand stage and a (relatively) lavish pocketbook, enough to justify playing with musical elements, massive soundstages, scores of extras, a wholly CG character or two, and the best 3D effects money could buy.  One might, perhaps, observe how "the best 3D effects money could buy" in the year prior to its ultimate 2010 release came from a film costing this project's budget three times over, and that the base material was shelved since 2007, and start to understand what went wrong.

Hubris is our watchword for today.  Hubris in thinking a production so plainly bloated by B-name theater actors' salaries and enormous soundstages could afford a little skimpiness on the effects budget, and so crafting a final product where flying effects and CG characters render as vaguely floating a few feet above the film rather than anywhere inside it.  Hubris in Tim Rice deciding his lyrical compositions for the musical numbers would not use Tchaikovsky's ballet pieces as a base and follow their lead with a complimentary rhythm, but rather be designed for singing along to every not, regardless of whether or not the resultant cadence sounds anywhere close to a natural register.  Hubris in believing many side characters so plainly charming on the face of it that we needn't see them between their too-brief introduction and an end-of-second-act crisis wherein they display none of their personality quirks again in favor of generic fantasy action platitudes.  Hubris in thinking spending the entire second act wholly detatched from the fantasy world and spinning our wheels on some domestic drama the film clearly doesn't care for is at all an acceptable way to stay within our budget when it really kills the pacing dead and causes many following beats to feel redundant.

Hubris with regards to the rats, oh my GOD, the rats.  I can only assume Konchalovsky and his contributors thought as far as, "Well other films use a little Third Reich imagery as shorthand for the bad guys, we can as well," and then trotted out said justification every time they wanted to add a little more.  The rats march around in full-blown SS uniforms, round up innocent people from the street, throw them into concentration camps, operate massive ovens designed to burn those they scapegoat as ruining the world, and talk up the eventual birth of a glorious rat masterrace and a Rat Empire which will last for one thousand years.  All right there, on the surface, no necessary distancing whatsoever, plain and simple Nazi stuff.  Let's not also forget, they still have rodent faces, rodent faces which look very much like Nazi propaganda caricatures of Jewish people besides, and most talk with heavy Italian/Brooklyn accents.  And listen, listen - while I am the world's foremost advocate for scaring kids through children's movies, the effects on John Turturro's face when his Rat King gets upset and he morph-roars into a monstrous rat face are all too much, all too distressing, and deployed all too frequently for how much I don't like looking at it.  Also, their arrival into the movie evokes 9/11 imagery, and Turturro electrocutes a pet shark at one point, for no reason other than making this whole thing more off-kilter and distressing.

Looking at The Nutcracker in 3D with a proper critical eye, though, trying to see beyond all the odd, excessive, easily-identifiable bad creative decisions, and figure out what really went wrong, I think the briefly mentioned structural problems drag the movie more than any of the Nazi rat stuff.  Don't get me wrong, unless we perform corrective surgery on the film, wholly remove all the Nazi motifs, and find literally any other thematic costuming as a replacement, it will always have that millstone round its neck, but figuring out the structural problems could help a lot.  You can get away with quite a bit if a story plays as familiar or resonant in the broad strokes, making your idiosyncrasies read as "Alright, go off but I'm with you" instead of "What in God's good name are you DOING?"  Bad as the Nazi rats, the child acting, and the effects compositing are, The Nutcracker in 3D's greatest weakness lies in how it flaunts conventional story structure in favor of a protracted second act in the real world, with all hints of the fantastical banished to the margins.  To illustrate my point, allow me to propose as potential alternative layout for the film, in which we only change the order and focus of events with minor eliminations to improve flow.

The first act, with Mary meeting the Nutcracker, exploring the expanded living room, and learning about the curse the Rat Queen placed upon him can play exactly as they do in the movie, except we move the introduction of the Nutcracker's three living doll friends over to the start of act 2, and place more focus on the developing relationship between the two.  Rather than spending the second act in the real world, Mary, the cured real boy Nutcracker Prince, and the doll companions spend their time trying to infiltrate the Rat Kingdom and overthrow the Rat King for good, only for the Rat King to discover them, kidnap the retransformed Nutcracker, and banish Mary and the dolls back to the real world.  THEN we can play out a shorter, tighter focused version of act 2's runaround as a start-of-act-3 crisis,and proceed with the movie's third act as is, only with better defined supporting characters and a stronger relationship between Mary and the Nutcracker. Compare this to how little screentime the two share in the film as-is, and how much of the back half of the second act is dedicated to rerunning the first act's set-up with new stakes while assuming we've any reason to invest, and the problem should be plain.  Spending so much time insisting Mary stay separated from the Nutcracker and the Rat Kingdom only serves to kill the film's capacity to engage an audience; a structure more in-line with traditional children's fantasy epics would help the piece flow, get us deeper into the weirder elements, and at least acclimatize us to the stranger elements in addition to strengthening the character work.

Or, as an alternate proposal, how about we keep the film's structure as is, weirdly lengthy return to reality and all, except we shift around our thematic focus instead?  Exact same movie up to the thirty-minute mark, except Mary's attempt to lift the Rat Queen's curse doesn't work, because for all the enchanting, fantastical sights around her, she doesn't really believe in what she's seeing just yet.  The sudden return to mundane reality thusly hits her harder, and her father's attempts to shake those silly dreams for her head has a tangible impact on her.  That whole meandering musical number where Uncle Albert sings about a magic pebble her father had as a boy connects more directly to Mary's story, and when the Nutcracker returns to bring Mary and her brother Max back for another try at liberation, she only goes reluctantly, and only invests fully for the third act because the Rat King kidnaps Max.  You can then run the third act as a simultaneous "Rescue my brother" narrative and a "I have to actually care and believe in all those childlike things like imagination and dreams" story, to boost up the effect when Mary finally lifts the curse and claims she never wants to leave this new home.  Just one change to one plot point and a shift in the main character's attitude, and you can make this odd structure work a little better.

I'm personally more into the first proposal than the second, for the first allows the film to indulge in its weird attempts at spectacle more openly than the second, which probably requires turning down the bombast to sell the audience on Mary's refusal to truly believe until the climax.  Either way, they both show how The Nutcracker in 3D didn't necessarily have to break so badly as it does.  There's so much "This is MY passion project, and we're doing it the way I like!" running through every aspect of the production, I've a hard time believing you could wrangle a wholly good or appealing story from the wreck, especially if we're really honestly truly married to doing Rat Nazis and not spending a proportionate amount of money on our effects.  With a different structure though, regardless of if it's more traditional or more suited to supporting a thematic idea, we might've seen a respectable if heavily flawed, too indulgent work that communicates something and delivers a mildly enjoyable experience.  It is broken and misconceived, but the foundations could've supported SOMETHING, rather than the haphazard mess we got.  Which, all told, is better than the total, doomed-from-the-start failure of the Tom and Jerry Nutcracker film.

(Let me tell you, it was REALLY distracting hearing Moaning Myrtle's voice coming from the Nutcracker's mouth the entire film.)

2/5

Thursday, December 19, 2019

Mixed Nutcrackers - The Nutcracker (1973) and Tom and Jerry: A Nutcracker Tale (2007)

It's a twofer today!  Tom and Jerry's film didn't even total to an hour, and was guaranteed to not appeal to a one of us, so we went and looped in a short animated film from Russia to pad out the time and ensure I wouldn't spend this review in conniptions over the poor quality of a bargain bin children's animated film!  Tally ho, onwards with the discussion!

***
Boris Stepantsev's short The Nutcracker is handily the best adaptation we've seen as part of Mixed Nutcrackers, and seems likely to rise as the best adaptation period when all's said and done.  It's quite an economical piece of storytelling, incorporating practically all important beats and elements from the Hoffmann story in a quick 25 minutes without losing any charm, and showing off some delightful animation in the process.  No need to reconstitute the elements into something wholly of its own kind, nor belabor the point with loud humor, nor wander off in its own direction after the introductory action, just the story of a young girl finding a Nutcracker in the Christmas tree, learning of his story, defending him against the Mouse King, and falling in love.  There's a bit of compression for time and effect, like rendering Marie a nameless servant girl with no godfather or younger brother to interfere in her journey, making the Princess Pirlipat and the Nutcracker Prince one and the same, freezing the Nutcracker's whole kingdom, and stripping the Land of Sweets segment of pretty much everything save an elegant dance (set to Waltz of the Flowers rather than the final number, which is instead used to underscore the Nutcracker's despair at his appearance) in order to give the stuff with the mice more focus, but otherwise the whole thing's here, and dances through the plot elegantly.

It's probably also the prettiest looking of the animated adaptations we've seen, with some of my favorite designs for each of the major characters.  I'm all about Marie's awkward, lanky appearance with big clogs in the place of the usual slippers and those round, curious eyes, the Nutcracker's rectangular shape and flexible mouth that never stops baring some nice square teeth, the Mouse Queen's three heads sharing a single gigantic crown atop a hunched body clad in deep blues and light purples, and her son's rotund design, which bloats into an imposing ball when he inherits her crown and becomes Mouse King.  In fact, similar to the Culkin-starring adaptation, I really like how all the mice share a similar rounded design, and delight in their more prominent screentime so we can look at their silly scurryings longer.  The backgrounds, I'm not entirely certain how to describe them... it's like they used watercolors that crystalized into impressionistic sheets of ice, giving the characters wonderfully detailed backdrops to play against whether they're in the appropriately-sized, pink and yellow king's court in flashback, or the barren dark blues and greens of the parlor at shrunken scale.  Environments varied as a Christmas tree full of ornaments or a blank stretch of wall are equally pleasing and rewarding to look at and follow details through in this manner.  Such detailed backgrounds also helps the characters' cleaner models stand out, and while this occassionally produces an effect whereby they float above the scenery rather than moving through, it also helps Marie and the Prince's final, transformitive dance wherein they shift between themselves and flower-petals as they glide through a reflective night sky of flashing light and color feel all the more magical.

This thing's good, spellbinding and embodying the childlike innocent wonder I found in the novella better than most.  It doesn't have my absolute favorite Nutcracker design, or Mouse King design, or battle between toys and mice (look to The Motion Picture, the Culkin film, and Fantasy for those respectively), but it gets the overall feel right and gratifies the viewer in a spritely timelimit.  Very nice to find something I can wholeheartedly appreciate without a sliver of irony or major critique in this marathon - a good last-minute Christmas present to the lot of us!

4/5

***
God, but do Tom and Jerry deserve better caretakers.  Y'all saw the Charlie and the Chocolate Factory memes last year, right?  The ones with all the awkward faces you think are smear frames but actually remain in unmoving focus for several seconds, the bizarre attempts to shoehorn Tom and Jerry into a pointless retelling of the 1971 movie, the endless reposting of that one Wonka smirk towards the end?  Bizarre and bad as it's said to be, I'd easily take such an approach to shoving the cat and mouse pair into The Nutcracker than whatever the hell is going down in A Nutcracker Tale.  Hoffmann's story is legit perfect for a seven-minute short in the style of those from the 40s and 50s - Tom and Jerry doing their usual antics, the whole part with the mouse army showing up and doing battle with the toy army happens, Jerry gets caught up in the press, Tom gets exploited as a prop weapon by the toys, we do a little runaround, we chomp the Nutcracker's teeth down on someone's tail, we play a few lines of Tchaikovsky, we go home.  If the ballet had its revival just a few years earlier, when Fred Quimby was still pumping out cartoons under the original Hanna-Barbera team and vying for Best Animated Short Oscars, I could see all the classic gags slotting handily into such a set-up.

Show of hands, who amongst you would ever guess a Tom and Jerry Nutcracker thing would involve Jerry idly wishing he could dance, being granted not only ballet talent by the voice of God who is also the narrator and also Santa and also emblamized by the Star of Bethlehem (called out as such by a character in the film, no less), but an entire magical kingdom of living toys to rule as Mouse King, which is ruined the second Tom and his alleycat friends wander in, and are granted automatic control of the kingdom by the same magic power, necessitating a quest to find the Toymaker across various thematically-incompatible dimensional planes?  And also Tuffy is there.

"Bizarre" is the word for this thing.  Beyond dressing everyone in old-fashioned army uniforms, keeping a Tara Strong-voiced tiny ballerina hostage for occasional asides, and quoting Tchaikovsky's music at the most inappropriate times, there's practically nothing here to theme this as a Nutcracker-based work, yet it has no identity of its own besides.  The creative team seemingly indulged every idea they had in the process of screenwriting and drawing layouts, clumping in random bits of overwrought drama they resolve inside seconds, trips inside a lair of snakedragons and through a Coney Island-style amusement park, an appearance by a Frankenstein-esque mad doctor cat, and many, many more little bits of incohesive weirdness.  It's hardly Nutcracker-themed, calling it Christmas-themed would do it injustice, it rarely does anything with the magical kingdom being confined to a theater, and multiple segments break away from something so simple as generic winter-based setting, so what is this meant to be?  I can't even claim it's to sell a soundtrack or take advantage of some tunes in the Warner Music Archive, because The Nutcracker's music is public domain.

One might claim it's meant to be all over the place and jumbled-up nonsense because anarchy was such an integral part of the theatrical cartoon landscape which birthed Tom and Jerry, but I'd argue it's nothing of the kind.  For one, it lacks any degree of self-awareness necessary to follow in the steps of something like Duck Amuck, and indeed asks the viewer take the various perils Jerry and company face in their journey completely seriously right before jarring fifty feet right into slapstick again.  Speaking of the slapstick for a far more important another, if throwing up our hands and going, "Screw it, we'll just do whatever we like!" is meant to be an OK thing to do because it gives rise to some good gags, it fails at such.  The outsourced cheapo Korean animation on display is slow, lifeless, and lacking in anything one might recognize as the wild, weighty energy of a classic Tom and Jerry short.  Gags dependent on physical humor are either too afraid to indulge in the old ways of a soddering iron to the noggin or a bowling ball down the gullet and so opt for weak variations on "character go flying and get hurt off-screen haha," or else go so terribly outlandish with a baffling lack of both build-up and suddenness that it doesn't work.  They all just sorta... happen, with no speed or purpose, and get easily overwhelmed by bad stand-up routines from talking characters, or the far too thick sentimentality, or an out of nowhere baseball joke.

I could handily rag on the film for ages, having a go at it's odd attempts to set lyrics to Tchaikovsky's music in the early going before dropping the atonal conceit; or make a try at delivering weak praise, saying the ornament character who's constantly coming unraveled might've had an interesting gimmick going if they animated his final disheveled state as anything other than a barely wiggling mass of string.  Considering, however, how the film ends on a limp series of gags as Jerry drives the cats from his about-to-vanish-forever kingdom with such a mediocre lack of creativity or fun, I don't think carrying on past this point necessary.  This is a flat corporate product - one which draws heavy, groaning sighs on the regular and is probably pretty bad to show your kids if you don't want them taking to YouTube comments sections and droning about how such a grey, inert film is an underrated classic ten years hence, but a flat corporate product all the same, and so deserving of an equally limp, lifeless end to this review.

I paid four bucks for this.  When the time comes for the anti-capitalist uprising and we're collectively dismantling all the major entertainment conglomorates, I'm gonna walk into the Warner Bros treasurer's office and ask for those back.

2/5

Sunday, December 15, 2019

Mixed Nutcrackers - Barbie in The Nutcracker (2001)


Fun fact: this marathon was originally conceived as an All-Barbie December, on the simple basis that Christmastime is a time for tormenting friends, and nothing could possibly equal the torment of promising a Nutcracker marathon, only to dovetail into a long collection of samey Barbie films with no warning.  Only trouble is, if we DID run an All-Barbie December, I'd have to watch all of those same Barbie films myself - and, even worse, WRITE about them.  Such a joke could not possibly sustain itself across a whole month and still produce good writing, so the series was quickly converted to a Nutcracker-a-thon, and here we are today.  You can still count Barbie as the centerpiece of the series, the crown jewel from whence all other films featured sprang forth, and a perfect embodiment of why we're doing Nutcracker stuff instead of Barbie stuff.  Because let me tell y'all right here right now, I do NOT have a lot to say about this one.

Not like I didn't have a lot to say about The Motion Picture, gosh no.  Go back and read the review, I had plenty to say, just no clue how to format it into a coherent, paragraph-based piece.  Barbie in the Nutcracker challenges because it is plainly aimed at the youngest audience yet, roundabouts the four-to-six demographic, and much as the joke reviews on Letterboxd insisting this has an ending to rival Mulholland Drive in complexity and confusion, something ready-made to stop holding appeal once you enter second grade does not offer many avenues for critique.  The simplicity leaves fewer dimensions to pick at, the purity of purpose makes slagging too hard bad sport, and the lack of nostalgia in my case in particular means I cannot articulate what makes it tick for someone who saw it at just the right age in the way someone born round the same time as myself but with a Barbie obsession in their past.  So, seeing as I do still have a few concrete points to walk across, we won't rely on bullet pointing, but we will theme by paragraph, and take some time to poke Barbie in the Nutcracker's merits as an adaptation of The Nutcracker/TheNutcracker and the Mouse King, its merits as a piece of animation, its merits as a piece of children's entertainment, and how it is effected by its status as part of the Barbie brand.  Should work out just fine; let's go.

As I've noted when discussing the various ballet-oriented adaptations, The Nutcracker has an inborn problem of dropping any semblance of narrative in the back-half in favor of pure dance, and even ETA Hoffmann's original story loses its slack once Marie and the Nutcracker Prince enter the Land of Sweets.  This requires any story-focused works to find some means of tinkering the material to suit its own needs, and we've seen a few differing approaches - Nutcracker Fantasy was more inspired by ideas from the story and crafted its own narrative from near-whole cloth, The Nutcracker Prince added more supporting characters and a bit of extra drama during the final movements, and the various ballets have the benefit of about half-a-dozen scripted dances for fodder.  Barbie, for her part, sticks to the basic rhythms of a young woman receiving presents on Christmas eve, becoming delighted by a nutcracker, and having a strange dream of a war between mice and toys, with a few minor alterations.  Her Aunt Elizabeth functionally replaces now-Grandfather Drosselmeyer as gifter and One Atop The Clock, there's no party or other toy soldiers because character models are expensive, and she doesn't wake from her dream once she drives away the Mouse King with her slipper.  This last marks the film's major departure, for once it's done with the literary source's first half inside fifteen minutes, it sets aside the rest of its remaining hour for a story of light high fantasy.

This basically works as a creative choice, because it decouples the movie from novella and ballet, and largely enables it to run its own little Christmas-themed thing.  Changing the Sugarplum Fairy to a Sugarplum Princess is a weird little bit of probably-necessary marketing tampering, but making her a McGuffin that Barbie, the Nutcracker, and a few hangers-on must seek out to free a fantasy kingdom from the Mouse King's iron clutch gives a fine excuse to keep introducing new concepts, constantly move forward without flagging in one spot for too long, and introduce a few little bits and bobs of its own.  I certainly didn't expect the Barbie Nutcracker movie to feature a massive rock golem chase or a talking bat sidekick, yet they're here all the same and functioning quite nicely.  Considering the way it all looks, Mattel could've easily taken the same assets and put out a token PC game with the same story.  That courtyard in the climax seems purpose-built as a boss arena, so why not?

With regards to looks... well, it's no great shake, but was there any chance otherwise?  Round 2001, only Pixar and Dreamworks had humanoid animation anywhere close to workable, and Pixar's whole "It's more believable and endearing because they're toys" idea with Toy Story also had a greater budget, more talented artists, far more detailed environments, a stronger lighting rig, and stylized characters who aren't confined by the semi-realistic proportions and sculpting of the Barbie line.  They tried, God bless 'em they tried, but there's a stiff lack of flair to the movements and the models are way too lacking in detail to read as anything except cheap.  Attempts at animating special effects like fairies dancing through the air as they fly look more like someone messing around with the drag-and-drop tool, and the little amount of dancing present seems heavily limited by what the models could do regardless of them using mo-cap.  The lighting effects are the biggest failure, as any attempt to do something creative gives the characters this weird fuzzy halo effect that ruins any illusion of them standing in their environment, while simpler set-ups make them look like the plastic they are.  All in all exactly what you'd expect from a direct-to-video 3D animation project of this time, but I still have to give props for the effort.  The animators at Mainframe and Mattel Entertainment could've easily lit the whole thing uniformly and made no swings at more complex animations they didn't have the budget or experience to handle.  Their failures speak more to willingness to experiment than lack of ability (though don't get me wrong, the execution lacks something fierce at times - that cloudy beachside scene is just the pits).

(Plus, they recognized their inability to fully model every outdoor environment, so several of them utilize digital mattes on the skyboxes and render a few more complex panoramic scenes as fully 2D paintings, which actually caught me off-guard at one point.  I was just about ready to mock the film for not knowing what the heck a Perspective is when they arrive at a magical castle, only for it to fall down because it's a cardboard fake planted by the bad guys, which just so happens to look identical to the style used on the flat backgrounds.  They got me good there!)

I think the whole thing holds together as a cartoon for really young kids pretty well.  Fun little out-and-back adventure type narrative with just enough daring-do to keep the boys engaged while remaining soft enough for the girls, if we are to think in terms of a Mattel-executive circa turn of the millennium.  As regular readers know, I'm perpetually gung-ho for a little bit've scary imagery bound to frighten small ones a little in any product, and the Mouse King's predilection for casually turning his minions and subjects to statuary checks that box quite nicely.  We had quite a lot of fun joking about how the dialogue-driven portions of the climax are effectively Mattel discoursing on the need for consent from the governed for an effective system of government, which satisfies the whole "Gotta have something for the parents!" aspect in a manner beyond the usual crude humor.  And really, while I'm baffled by the large percentage of reviews from supposedly full-grown adults that seem to genuinely have a hard time understanding the ending (Dream real; nothing more, nothing less), the whole thing with Barbie turning out to be the Sugarplum Princess and Prince Eric being real outside the dream probably does work as a series of effective twists for anyone of the right age.  Thumbs up from me on this metric.

If there is a real weakness I can dig at here without feeling bad for going after something made for very small children with the same vigor I do more mature films or animators in circumstances unfriendly to more polished work, I think the film's position as part of the Barbie brand harms it most.  The whole thing is framed as Barbie telling a story to her... I think sister, as a means of helping her gain confidence during her ballet lessons, and the fact that main character Clara is more Barbie as Clara than a person herself leaves the film unable to pursue its ideas to the fullest.  Other characters claim Clara is a strong, brave, confident person whose presence keeps the party together and gives the Nutcracker the strength to outmatch the Mouse King, but Barbie can't do anything we might interpret as off-brand, so these qualities only come through because the characters say so.  Otherwise she's just moving from place to place and setting up more important conversations, which limits its ability to impart any positive message to its audience.  The whole thing with "Barbie was a beautiful princess all along and lives happily ever after!" comes through on a "I'm four and don't know what stories or dialogue are" level far clearer than "Barbie becomes a beautiful princess because she's a capable person who uses her inner strength to earn her happy ending" aspect.  Not to mention, ending on a scene of Barbie and her sister dancing a variation on the Sugarplum Fairy piece with step-to-step perfection kinda undercuts Barbie as a positive big sister rolemodel by having her teach it perfectly the first time with no need for anything beyond telling a story.  At least the sister struggling a little but doing better than she did at the start would've made it stronger.

Yeah, I know I'm giving way, way more credence and critique to a Barbie film than it probably merits, but one has to at least try and treat all films equally if we want everyone across all ages and outlooks to have good movies made for them.  Far, far easier to do so for a children's film than something made for members of another racial identity or sexual orientation, given we've all got some variation on that childhood experience, and I think Barbie in the Nutcracker deserves a little effort anyhow.  One can tell the crew put forth their level best for the circumstances, and while it's not great or even to my personal standards of wholly good (that lighting really kills it for me), it does what it wants to do well, and also allows Tim Curry a chance to go whole ham on the digital scenery.  Nobel goals fulfilled adequately.  Bout all one can ask for and be happy with when dealing with Barbie, I'd say, least till they had the idea for Life in the Dreamhouse and got meta with it.

(Here's some fun trivia for you - the Nutcracker's VA, Kirby Morrow, served as Goku in Ocean Group's dub of Dragon Ball Z from episode 160 onwards, while Ian James Corlett (Captain Candy) served as Goku in Saban's initial dub of the anime, and Peter Kelamis (Primm the Bat) replaced him in the Saban dub before serving in the same capacity in the Westwood dub.  Got three Gokus up in here.  Neat!)

3/5

Thursday, December 12, 2019

Mixed Nutcrackers - The Nutcracker (1993)


SEVEN HEADS ALERT!  SEVEN HEADS ALERT!  I REPEAT, THE MOUSE KING SHOWS UP IN 1993'S THE NUTCRACKER, AND HE HAS THE FULL, PROPER SEVEN HEADS.  THREE MOLDED COPIES OF THE CENTRAL HEADPIECE JUTTING OUT FROM BOTH SIDES, YOU COUNT 'EM UP, YOU'VE GOT ONE TWO THREE FOUR FIVE SIX SEVEN FULL HEADS!  HE AIN'T IN IT MUCH,  BUT HE MATCHES THE PROPER COUNT, AND HE'S GOT THE SAME DELIGHTFULLY ROUNDED, BAGGY BODY SUIT AS THE REST OF THE MOUSE SOLDIERS.  FIVE OUTTA FIVE.  TEN OUTTA TEN.  BEST MOVIE OF THE YEAR ALL YEARS.


Ahem.

So, this take on The Nutcracker is a bit of an odd beast.  Despite an alternate title naming it after George Balanchine's famous, life-giving and fame-bringing 1954 version of the ballet and despite drawing extensively from Peter Martin's then-present rendition, the film's overall construction gives one the impression it only exists because Kit Culkin couldn't negotiate satisfactory terms for payments on Home Alone 3, and rushed a film version of a Christmastime ballet into production so his son would have a starring role in a holiday film for the winter '93 season.  Macaulay Culkin is quite a bit more prominent than other Nutcrackers and their princely counterparts, entering the story alongside Drosselmeyer and getting teased as a potential romantic interest for Marie during the children's dancing scenes at the Christmas party.  He's got a substantial number of close-ups compared to the other major players, which reveal how Kit evidently instructed Macaulay to not move a single solitary facial muscle during the entire production, and consequently makes it seem weird the child actor so well known for his expressiveness in the Home Alone movies is playing it so dead-eyed.  Some of that might come from how Kit very obviously didn't drop a single cent on ballet lessons for Macaulay, who is asked to perform the Nutcracker Prince's dancing recap of his battle against the Mouse King (notably deleted from The Motion Picture), and does so by awkwardly shuffling in place, occasionally flourishing his arms a tiny bit, and overall looking like he does not want to be here.  Much as Tchaikovsky's ballet has the leads' absence throughout the second act baked into its traditional form, Culkin's presence makes the issue all the more head-scratching, for the constant focus on his person throughout the first act gives way to he and Clara simply sitting on the sidelines watching the cultural and candy dances with very few close-ups, and not even performing the play's final dance.  Y'all paid for The Kid What Did Home Alone In This Other Christmas Thing, now thrill as he embodies none of the traits you liked from that movie, and then gets benched so the real dancers can dance.

Course, the real dancers here aren't quite equal to those from the Bolshoi Company or the Pacific Northwest Ballet.  Lacking in technical knowhow about ballet and dance in general though I am, exposure to their filmed productions tells me there's something oddly simple about the performances here.  The group pieces are all fairly fine to my eye, big crowds in motion always having some positive effect on me regardless of technical execution, and their costumes are pretty and eye-catching all-round, so a large group in matching outfits of this type is going to work for me.  Problems arise with the solo or paired dancers, whose movements seem rather slow and restricted - the ballerina playing the Sugarplum Fairy seems especially simple and sluggish during her highlight numbers by comparison.  I have to wonder how much of these underwhelming dances are the result of my spoiling by viewing world-class performers and no one else immediately prior to this viewing, how much comes from a lack of vim and vigor during this particular production, and how much blame one can lay upon director Emile Ardolino.  I've not seen Dirty Dancing, but its reputation as one of the great dance movies led me to expect better staging and camerawork.  Where the Bolshoi production has the excuse of being a filmed live performance, and The Motion Picture works a few tricks to ease into its theatrical staging, Ardolino presents the film as 80% head-on filming of obvious stagebound sets, and renders his rare close-ups or alternate angles disappointing in effect thanks to a lack of acting from anyone onstage.  I singled out Culkin for his lifelessness due to his prominent treatment, but pretty much everyone here lacks an awareness that the camera might find them interesting at a distance any closer than fifty feet.  Such simple performances might work when viewed as live theater (not ever Nutcracker staging needs to bring the house down and strain the performers past their limits) or even filmed theater, but with the bare-minimum effort at treating this film like a movie in hand, the unimpressive footwork and static camera should make it a bit of a slog to watch.

Connie thought so, and I see where she's coming from... yet I found myself far more engaged by this production than the Bolshoi version or The Motion Picture.  I cannot call this film better than either, as despite some pretty backdrops and outfits (and those INCREDIBLE mice, ho boy!), its production design doesn't quite match the former's creativity or the latter's richness, and both contain what seem to me far better dancing.  Kevin Kline's perfunctory narration should seem insulting, and does little to help once one realizes how well the same information is communicated without words even here, and there's just simply not much here I might call exemplary.  Charming to an extent, visually pleasant, containing a mouse king with the proper seven heads as God intended, yes, but not great.  And again, here I am with a film I think lesser compared to The Motion Picture that kept me alive and awake far better.  I'm inclined to say some of it comes down to growing familiarity with both the general form and this particular show, and having multiple different points of comparison against which to actively go, "It's interesting how they're handling the cultural dances this time, and the different placement on the Sugarplum Fairy's dance has an odd effect on the flow, and what are the limited cinematic flourishes doing for the film compared to the others when they'll sometimes take the form of a slow flashback to events we saw five minutes ago, and and and?"  It's probably not so much this film having anything particularly special to stimulate my brain, as it is me having poisoned my brain with so much Nutcracker content in the past few weeks as to find the act of comparing and contrasting different versions more rewarding than I did when watching The Motion Picture a week back.  Call it engagement by way of being a fucking nerd.

Harshness aside, this staging of The Nutcracker probably simply made an ill-fit for the cinematic form.  Drawing on Connie's after-film musings again, I'd agree many of the flaws I've highlighted wouldn't stand out so prominently on the stage, considering the lack of a camera to underline the lack of emotive acting and its own inability to dance in time would remove the pressure to live up as a piece filmmaking, and the longer-standing tradition of live ballet productions compared to versioned film as film would remove the impulse to compare it to productions more specifically geared to take advantage of the medium.  In this particular mode, however?  S'fine.  Fun to poke fun at how wooden Culkin's dad made the thing by shoe-horning his famous son in, enjoyable to watch when the bodies are in motion, and happily free from the pedophilic subtext present in the ballet - or, for that matter, the textual text present in The Motion Picture.  This last really helps me find a positive spin on the film at the end of the day.  Drosselmeyer may become a bit of a dead-end character if he's not constantly present throughout the dream sequences, but if the alternative is a consciously creepy rendition orchestrating the dances in the Land of Sweets as a means of stealing young Clara's hand away from her ideal fantasy boyfriend, then LET'S play schmaltzy, cutesy child romance with no godfather in sight.  Please.

3/5

10/5 for the Mouse King

Monday, December 9, 2019

Mixed Nutcrackers - The Nutcracker Prince (1990)


Here's somethin' interesting for you - whilst watching the credits to The Nutcracker Prince last night, I noticed how a substantial portion round the middle was dedicated to "opaquers."  The term's alien to me and doesn't make its description obvious on first look, so I spent a little while Googling it, trying to find some reference to the profession of opaquing as it pertains to the film or animation industry.  My efforts were for naught, and the only reference I found to opaquing beyond dictionary definitions for "making something opaque" came from the imdb credits page for this very film.  It seems really strange for a film to have 168 artists credited for a single job I can't find any reference to online, especially when every other credit pertaining to people who designed, laid out, animated, photographed, and cut the film totaled to 176 persons, a mere eight more for every other part of making the drawings move than whatever an opaquer does.  What's going down here?  What secrets do you hide, O The Nutcracker Prince?

I've a working theory on this, and I'd love to hear any information proving it wrong, because it speaks to some unfortunate business practices if it's right.  Of those 168 opaquers, 37 are credited in a special section for Opeongo High School, Ontario-located home to graduate Kevin Gills.  Gills served as The Nutcracker Prince's screenwriter and sole credited producer, and quite a large portion of the non-celebrity voice cast were drawn from acting contributors to his cartoon The Raccoons.  It's also worth noting how, despite the film's listings noting production by Lacewood Productions, the animation credits here name Hinton Animation Studios, a studio which fell to crippling debts mid-production and was reconstituted into Lacewood prior to release.  All this, in combination with the "opaquers" coming just after the the xerographers and matching department people, leads me to believe "opaquer" is a deliberately twisted term for "colorist," one not covered under union protections, and so an easy way for a producer operating on a tight budget to cut a few costs on his film.  Why pay a few professional colorists at scale when you can farm the operation out to a whole bunch've people for very little money, and still not pay as much as if you'd hired any union-backed folks?  You can even get a little work from the high school and not pay a dime!

Now, as I mention, this is largely speculation.  I confess I don't know too much about how many workers it typically takes to get the colors done on an animated film compared to the other departments, and it's possible the use of high schoolers could come down to Gills paying his dues and offering his old school a program for teens to get a little experience in the professional filmmaking world for school credit.  There's easily a non-sinister interpretation of events if you look for it.  However, I'm not too inclined to believe it sight unseen over thinking the practice unethical, as there are still oddities in the credits like assigning a single artist to produce the backgrounds for a solid fifteen minute chunk of film where the other background artists would only need paint roughly five-and-a-half minutes assuming roughly even distribution, or the downright odd aversion to the word "colorist" when character designers are followed immediately by "character colour design."  Something don't quite add up here to my eye, and I'd love to hear from anyone more in the know about these things than me, because I'm really quite baffled.  Is "opaquer" a common job title up in Canadian production houses, or have I really found a weird cost-cutting measure?

As one might guess from the three paragraphs focused on accreditation more than anything in the film, The Nutcracker Prince gives one reason to think it made on the cheap.  It's not particularly egregious about any of these, and looks quite nice in places for what they had, but you can TELL they weren't exactly throwing around money to spare during production.  A few of the more impressive, fluid pieces of animation get reused in the same context wholesale, faster movements trend towards choppiness and lower detail compared to the norm, and numerous actions that seem best suited to smooth execution across a single shot are broken into their individual components across multiple edits and focused on as complete actions in their own right, completely killing any illusion of naturalness.  What's more, the aforementioned fifteen-minute chunk of the film with its own background artist is so thanks to a shift in the artstyle towards something far simpler and cartoonier, which effectively means the more complex, Disney-inspired animation only requires 50 minutes finished work rather than 65.  Fine as it appears in places, including some rather impressive on-screen transformations and big gestures given the clear crunch, the crunch is still clear, and marks the film as one produced under tight conditions.

Much as I'm inclined to note its low-budget, I don't much hold this against the film.  As I keep stressing, the designs work for what they are with one or two little stand-outs (primarily the Mouse King, who looks nicely frazzled and burly), the backgrounds have a good gentle quality about them, and some of the animations had me impressed at what they could pull off on not a lot've money.  The big art style shift actually works to the film's favor in my mind, as the character designs shared across both styles read better with the thinner lines, lighter colors, and slightly lesser detailing.  Its embrace of a zanier, late 50s sketchy-mod-look-embracing Looney Tunes aesthetic also helps the film's louder, slapstickier elements feel more natural, and leaves a satisfying sensation in the mind once it's all over and done with.  I very much enjoy the dedication to showcasing sequences sure to frighten small children in the audience, as when the Mouse King is stalking Clara with a fatal wound in his chest while all the animate dolls revert back to wood and plush.  We might not have artistic triumphs here, but the artistic moderate accomplishments get the idea across on their own level all the same.

Heck, with regards to the plot and story, I appreciate how much The Nutcracker Prince draws from ETA Hoffmann.  It's pretty much the same plot points in largely the same order, with details like Clara bargaining with the Mouse King after his supposed initial defeat and the passage through the Land of Sweets left intact.  We're even free from a creepy Drosselmeyer again, which I think will only be possible through these animated adaptations - the instinct to move FAR away from "what if an eight-year old's sexual awakening by way of her godfather's tricky machinations" is absolutely the right instinct.  Where the film REALLY falls down comes with its confidence in the material.  Paul Schibli and Kevin Gillis have, if not a time-tested classic, at least a well-worn, simple template on their hands, and no good reason to tack on additional details or rearrange the structure, but they do all the same.  For example, just as Nutcracker Fantasy's Tchaikovsky quotations were rather sparse and token, here the snippets from the ballet's score come far too frequently, and are overly front-loaded.  Recognizable melody follows Christmastime staple with little time for the score to cool its heels, and before we're past fifteen minutes we've used practically everything the general public might know, thus leaving the rest little to pull out for something fresh, beyond an admitedly clever use of the final waltz across multiple emotional tones.  There's too much eagerness to prove we're doing The Nutcracker, which leaves the film a bit sonically lacking as it goes on.

When considering their lack of confidence in the novella's story and structure, the problems multiply.  The battle against the Mouse King's forces and the journey into the Land of Sweets now requires the presence of multiple new doll characters to provide further slapstick comedy and exposition about the nature of the fantasy world and its kingdom, which mark a transparent grab for inattentive children's eyes.  They're not particularly enjoyable or dignified parts, especially not Peter O'Toole's elderly, bumbling toy general, who I feel earnestly sorry he ever had to voice for any reason.  Parts must've not been very good at the time.

Our biggest issue, though, comes with the exact placement of The Hard Nut flashback segment, the prior discussed 15-minute artstyle shift.  Rather than coming between the two battles between Nutcracker and Mouse King, it is positioned at the fifteen-minute mark during the opening Christmas party, and concludes at the half-hour mark, leaving the following forty-five minutes to work through the book's first and third acts back to back.  This speaks to a distinct lack of trust in the young audience to go along with the magic of toys and mice fighting without a full explanation for why there are magic toys and talking mice that don't get along beforehand, and sets bad precedent for the film to come.  Positioning such wild silliness gives the rest of the film justification to play its comedy broad and loud even when it doesn't match the more Disney-esque artwork, and leaves us with the odd problem of characters showing up to establish their gimmick and subsequently reappearing to bring it to conclusion in the space of five minutes.  Placing the flashback where it naturally sits in Hoffmann's work, as effectively the middle act, would not only break up the action and hopefully dissuade the surrounding film from going as broad as it does, but maintain the sense of wonder and magic around that first battle, perhaps hooking an unattentive audience better than "here's some exposition but it's really silly" does.

This constitutes a LOT more words than I anticipated spilling over a minor forgotten piece of 90s children's animation based on The Nutcracker, so I feel a little bad gritting my teeth and giving it the lower rating between the two I teased in my head for most of the day.  After all, despite some shrillness in the comedy and sloppiness in the animation shouldn't entirely overwhelm a solid if unremarkable overall production.  Poor construction and lack of faith are poor construction and lack of faith, however, and I've my suspicions that the same team working under the same circumstances would've produced a stronger film if they'd stuck to what they had and didn't feel the need to, for want of a better phrase, dumb it down by tweaking the order of events and adding more trendy elements for their day.  The gentler aspects of the original story are what spoke to me most, and something trying for an early prototype version of 90s eye-rolling and purposeful tone breaking just can't get all the way over the pass line in my house.  Plus, y'know, much as one shouldn't let behind-the-scenes stuff effect their viewing unless it's concrete and doing active harm to someone, I really can't shake the notion that they weren't paying their colorists a living wage during production, and that's just shitty if it's the case.  Please, please tell me I'm off-base on this.

(It's really all down to the Mouse King - a crooked tail and a hair-trigger temper do NOT compensate for one lousy head.)

2.5/5

Sunday, December 8, 2019

Mixed Nutcrackers - Nutcracker: The Motion Picture (1986)


Is it the form, the ballet, or just me?  I ask because I really am giving pure ballet the fairest shake I can manage when watching these films predicated on capturing the dances above telling a story, but there's something in their construction which leaves me incapable of engaging to the degree I'd like, and ending up kinda bored.  With the Bolshoi production we watched to start this holiday project, such issues weren't a problem, what with it serving as my introduction to the piece and the form on stage in general, and also its being an introductory piece viewed more as context than a work unto itself.  With Nutcracker: The Motion Picture, there's just enough of the stuff I know about moviemaking and conventional narrative-based storytelling for me to get acquitted and start settling in for a proper watch, only for the film to shift into pure dance for a solid forty minute period, with very little in the way of prior narration or contextualizing shots to string it along.  My eyes glaze over, and I have a highly difficult time getting back into the swing of things.  Hence my question: is it my inexperience with the technical side of ballet that means I cannot adequately discuss and analyze large portions of the movie in the proper manner, the fact that The Nutcracker will almost always transform into exhibition rather than story when bound to Tchaikovsky's compositions, or am I simply not a ballet person?

However y'slice it, I struggle in finding an overarching perspective to use as framework for this review.  It is, then, perhaps inevitable I finally break down and rely on my old friend, Bullet Pointing The Review For The Sake Of Getting It Done And Not Sitting Round Without Writing Anything For Another Goddamned Day.  Little as I like calling their assistance, they're quite handy when invited over.  So, let's disjointedly discuss!


  • Per the Wikipedia page, director Carroll Ballard thought Godfather Drosselmeyer a creepy character without a sympathetic angle, and elected to change this by giving him more focus throughout the film.  His methods for doing this involve affording Drosselmeyer an extended montage wherein he conceptualizes and crafts all the ballet's players, sets, and props before falling asleep as a miniature stage opens on Clara's dream; filming Drosselmeyer's dancer in close-up and emphasizing his desire for Clara's attention during the Christmas party scenes; and positioning a dream version of Drosselmeyer as not only mischevious imp in the background of act 1's back half and select portions of act 2, but an actively intervening figure who serves as taskmaster over the dancers in the Land of Sweets, and seems to covet Clara's hand in marriage over the Nutcracker's.  If any of this is meant to immediately and obviously clear away the pedophilic underpinnings inherent to the work's exploring a preteen's sexual awakening by way of her creepy godfather's attentions, I don't quite see how.  No matter how much Clara's narration insists she loved Drosselmeyer as a paternal figure despite all the times he's distressed and frightened her, all we as the audience see is the frightening parts, and a dream version whose advances and machinations recast otherwise delightful dances as insidious attempts to steal Clara away from the other, far more valiant suitor.  That one can read the Nutcracker Prince as a stand-in for Clara's innocent romanticism doesn't help Drosselmeyer's case, nor does the fact that he's acted as a vaguely concerning person on all three levels of the film's reality.  I read the director saying "sympathetic," but all I see is "more overtly villainous."
  • The above said, I think Ballard's other attempts to make the movie more cinematic do function fairly well, particularly his conception of the war between toys and mice.  The Pacific Northwest Ballet's production already looks to have involved quite a lot've moving parts to achieve the classic effect of the set and its prominent Christmas tree growing around Clara, and subsequently swarming the stage with a large number of bodies dressed as toy and mice soldiers.  Ballard gives the whole thing a nice boost with some highly intricate effects work that's still grounded in the props and possibilities of a stage production, and adds in an ever-mutating Mouse King who physically grows and shifts behind the cuts to become this thirty-foot tall, six-headed (almost seven, give me SEVEN, dammit!) monster by the sequence's end.  I've no idea if Ballard or Kent Stowell and Mauriece Sendak (choreographer and production designer on the stage production) came up with the Nutcracker's dancer running round in a gigantic mascot head for the battle scene, but whoever did so had a killer idea.  It photographs really well on film, and the clumsy, leaping movements it draws from the dancer gives the Nutcracker a great deal of personality, far beyond the generic prince he becomes for act 2.  The bit with Clara and the Nutcracker crawling into the Mouse King's gigantic discarded robes also makes a good effect.
  • Despite the Christmas party sequence being shot on a set with enough coverage to establish a firm set of filmic fourth walls all round, I'd call it a good decision for Ballard to have leaned into his material's stage origins more and more as the film goes on.  The battle sequence, once through with its shifting, expanding props, takes place in a great black void somewhere between film and stage in nature, and once Clara and the Nutcracker Prince fall in love during the snowflake dance, their surroundings look far more like a theatrical production, painted backdrop and all.  When the film makes a shift to act 2, it employs the classic waving bits of cardboard water effect on a grand scale to achieve the look of Clara and the Prince sailing to a grand palace, and then stages the vast majority of the following dances on an obvious stage.  Think the way Gilliam shot the play portions of The Adventures of Baron Munchhausen, straight on with the curtains and the surrounding area clearly visible, the lights plainly just off-camera.  Doing this builds an understanding amongst the audience about diving deeper into a dreamscape whilst embracing the stage's ability to feel more believably unreal than anything too concretely cinematic, and personally gives me something to appreciate while failing to engage with the dancers.
  • In view of the above, I'm not quite sure the opening dream sequence was quite the best idea.  It takes the form of Clara tossing in fits in her sleep as blue-screened versions of herself, her younger brother, an ambiguous prince, and a mouse dance and fight their way across her mattress.  Clever, but not quite in line with how the film proceeds otherwise, and a bit of a dead end for anything other than unsettling the audience after a series of scenes that have already done the same.  The film takes its time getting into anything familiar, and while I can appreciate the impulse in trying to make this The Creepier Take on The Nutcracker, the music and dances otherwise carry on like we're working a more conventional angle, so the early and uncharacteristic nature of this dream both throws the pace off balance and contributes to a bit of (I suspect) unintended tonal dissonance.
  • I can confirm after this viewing, the Arabic dance DOES go on substantially longer than the surrounding three other cultural dances.  Still absolutely no idea why Tchaikovsky wrote it that way, and in this production its length does no favors to the bird-plumage-leotarded solo dancer's efforts in a moment when I'm already struggling to stay in the film.  The Chinese and Russian dances, however, do benefit from its length, as the already surprising and delightful bit of a squat lion-costumed man being used as a maypole by many children, and the three bounding, shirtless, gold-spackled black dancers woke me right the hell up more than I suspect the same material would've with a less lengthy lead-in.
  • Regardless of how little I know of ballet, regardless of how ill-able I am to discuss its particulars and the details of the dancers' efforts (I know absolutely nothing of positions, job names, or technique descriptions), and even knowing a filmic production like this would be able to run multiple takes and not do it all in one go, the strength and skill involved in making Clara and the Nutcracker Prince's final, triumphant dance work is stunning and admirable all the same.  Finishing it with a quick return to the bobble-headed regular Nutcracker gives me a nice last reason to smile as well.
I've no pretty bow to tie this all up with, no elegant package to box it within, but I hope the above is at least adequate reading.  Writing about Nutcracker: The Motion Picture in full would doubtlessly devolve into my whinging about how bored and unentertained I am by a medium I rarely imbide, and doing so seems so out of spirit for the project and season.  I'd far rather run the risk of making little sense by dancing round a few bullet-pointed ideas than ram through a conventionally-styled review in which I let my ignorance of how to talk about much of the film's contents dominate.  Knowing how, unfortunately, 1993's The Nutcracker is also primarily filmed ballet fills me with a bit of dread, but if we need to invite my overly-long-named friend to get through that too, so be it.  Just so long as there's something interesting to talk about.

3.5/5

Tuesday, December 3, 2019

Mixed Nutcrackers - Nutcracker Fantasy (1979)


Much as I'd like to preemptively declare Sanrio's Nutcracker Fantasy the weirdest film we'll watch for this marathon, I shan't do so.  It's far too early for any statement so definitive, particularly when I've watched the trailer to Nutcracker and the Four Realms multiple times over the past week in a vain attempt to understand how and why it happened.  This said, today's film does make a fairly convincing case for the title, being a stop-motion animated work that rejiggers pieces of the ETA Hoffman story into a wholly new form inspired by The Wizard of Oz and Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, with animation courtesy of several Rankin/Bass overseas animators.  Per imdb's cast and crew page, those who worked on this film weren't CREDITED for much on their American televised work - director and editor Takeo Nakamura only has Santa Claus Is Comin' To Town listed as an animator, while puppet producer Sadao Miyamoto worked on Frosty the Snowman as an uncredited animator, Tadahito Mochinaga served as puppet technician and cinematographer on Mad Monster Party and animation supervisor on Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer, and puppet designer Ichirô Komuro went on to serve as production supervisor on several of the company's 80s productions.  Only four major names I can find amongst the credited crew in total, but considering how lax most visual presentations were about giving due credit to everyone who worked on a project beyond department heads (especially where foreign workers were concerned), and considering it shot at Mochinaga's own MOM Production studio same as the Rankin/Bass specials, I have to imagine there was more behind-the-camera experience with the form and style than one can ascertain from the on-screen accreditation.

Without the budgetary and time limitations of producing for an American televised holiday market, and with the eye and money of a booming Sanrio (backed by five years of Hello Kitty sales) on their side, Nakamura and crew show what this style of stop-motion can really do with Nutcracker Fantasy.  Sets are substantially larger and more detailed than in the familiar Christmas specials, with the lovingly dressed, two-story foyer of Clara's home and the Mouse Queen's sprawling lair standing out as particularly impressive examples.  Large crowds of characters are not only possible at a greater frequency than in Rankin/Bass' productions, they also boast a wide assortment of unique character designs, rarely resorting to mothballed old props or copycat clones.  When sets of characters with the same appearance do show up, it's justified by the presence of armies of mice and wind-up soldiers, spiced up by the addition of odd-looking generals, and more than compensated for by staging a lively, multi-plane battle with several layers of action across the horizontal and vertical plane both.  The camera's also far more lively than one typically sees with this style, crawling through the dolls and transitioning across interesting composite editing effects.  Special effects too benefit from the loftier breathing room, with far more intricate and lively integration of sparkling lights and specialized sets for trick camera moves, well beyond the overlaid gauze and animated snowflakes of Rankin/Bass' work.  I have to wonder how much Sanrio's aesthetic needs and demand for quality, or else the animators' decade-long experience with the style influenced the production, for Mad Monster Party was also produced for a theatrical release, and still suffers from the same limitations as its televised counterparts.

As an adaptation of The Nutcracker, Nutcracker Fantasy is actually a pretty fascinating reworking.  In as succinct a manner as I can manage: they've taken Godfather Drosselmeyer's story about how the Nutcracker came to be with the Mouse Queen and the cursed princess and the hard-to-crack nut, transplanted it into something inspired by the looks of the Land of Sweets without the candy themeing but with the large assortment of foreign dignitaries, expanded the conflict with an ongoing war reminiscent of the opening movement's mice/toys battle, and presented it all as a maybe dream/maybe reality situation, which nicely encapsulates every important element of Hoffmann's story.  It takes far more cues from medieval fantasy and lost girls stories, given how Clara's part for much of the story is to stand on the sidelines listening and worrying, but it's quite a clever way to rope in so much detail that's otherwise dropped from the ballet.  Some portions seem drawn from the ballet, as when the foreign wisemen are clamoring over one another to propose solutions in a manner reminiscent of their dances (just with far, FAR more nations and... ethnicities, shall we say, represented).  There's even a nod to the astronomer from Drosselmeyer's story, through the Queen of Time, whose mystical, heavenly figure of sagely advice is achieved through traditional ningyō jōruri rather than stop-motion.  S'all very neat to behold, and coupled with the aesthetics of the piece, it manages to give the film its own identity while paying clear homage to its progenitor, which mark good qualities for an adaptation.

When the film plays with its own material, it's not always quite so charming.  The beginning takes several minutes to establish a sinister Rag Man figure who seems like he'll play a major role, yet drops clean out've the narrative once the Nutcracker portions begin.  I'd suspect his loss has something to do with the English dub (the only one easily available, unfortunately) chopping out about ten minutes of footage, including two live-action dance segments, though I cannot find any substantial information on the differences.  More probably common to both versions is the court of foreign wisemen, which turns entirely on lazy stereotype humor, and mostly gets past my hackles for its clear demonstration of how varied the puppet design is in this film, as well as containing both a joke about Stalin's five year plan AND an offhand reference to Der Fuehrer's Face, both of which threw me for a loop.  The film's attempts to give Clara something to do in the climax mostly center on her wandering through a magic forest and meeting several symbolic original figures who lack much of what makes the Queen of Time interesting to watch and consider.  Most they have going being voiced by Christopher Lee, with one seeing him attempt a rather bad Irish accent.  It really must be said, while it's admirable to try and exercise Clara's emotional intelligence during this stretch, prior to the effort she has nothing to do but stand around waiting for the plot to move on, rendering her an undynamic protagonist in love with the soldier-turned-Nutcracker Franz because he looks handsome and heroic.  And, well...

I say the story's weaker when it's striking out into its own concepts, when I should really say it's at the weakest when it pulls in the one thing I'd never have imagined we'd pull from the Hoffmann story.  The reasoning behind the Mouse Queen's ire, I get snipping it out.  Clara not throwing her slipper to distract her an afford the Nutcracker a win, weird considering the ballet keeps this and makes it a more decisive action than in the story, but whatever, the sequence plays out fine on its own.  Making the secret to cracking the nut and breaking the Mouse Queen's power a pearl sword rather than someone's teeth, I guess I'm fine with it despite lessening the importance of Franz becoming a Nutcracker - these puppets don't exactly have articulate jaws.  But having Clara awake from her dream, meet her visitor Fritz, find him identical to Franz, and get married to him despite a doubtless decade-or-more age gap betwixt them?  Hoy.  Bad enough an implication when it's the 1810s and marital customs were far different than now.  Even accounting for this film's still-40 year age and differences in Japanese culture, it's still a bit of a Thing to take the story beyond a young girl's self-flattering dream world and into "They actually literally got married in real life and went to live in her fantasy kingdom, which is real, forever."  Gets one chewing one's cheek lining in discomfort, and makes some of the wholesomeness drain out've the story, not at all helped by how Clara's undying love as the only thing that can save the Nutcracker from his transformed state dropping into the story a few minutes prior with a "We've been trying to tell you this was the case all along!" line, despite this very much not being the case.  You were trying to tell her the kingdom of toys and ethnic stereotypes needed saving from a two-headed mutant mouse monster so your newfound beloved could marry someone else entirely.  Don't try to sell me a story you weren't telling in the final minutes, even if I'm in your target audience, and especially don't heavily imply a marriage between child and teenager at best, child and adult at worst.

There's other problems with Nutcracker Fantasy, mostly pertaining to the English dub - the voice acting is serviceable at best, the inclusion of Tchaikovsky snippets token, the American musical numbers not really to the standard of what their contemporaries were producing, which don't do much for me anyhow.  Taking it all into account and looking for the right ribbon with which to it it in a bow, though, I think an ultimately positive assessment is in order.  The spectacle of seeing Rankin/Bass' particular take on stop-motion design and animation given greater cinematic flair and polish than I've ever seen leaves a big impression, and the way it remixes The Nutcracker and the Mouse King into its own mini-fantasy war plot whilst homaging the source material leaves me with charm aplenty to overcome the less than stellar original material.  Just the simple fact of the Queen of Time's live puppetry amidst this collection of invisibly maneuvered figures is a memorable and impressive enough testament to the creativity on display here to get me over the "why are we implying child marriage?" hurdle.  A strong start to the holiday programming proper, and one I hope at least one non-Fantasia film can surpass before the month's out.

(Points for giving at least one mouse monarch multiple heads.  We'll see if anyone managed the full seven.)

3.5/5