Monday, December 9, 2019

Mixed Nutcrackers - The Nutcracker Prince (1990)


Here's somethin' interesting for you - whilst watching the credits to The Nutcracker Prince last night, I noticed how a substantial portion round the middle was dedicated to "opaquers."  The term's alien to me and doesn't make its description obvious on first look, so I spent a little while Googling it, trying to find some reference to the profession of opaquing as it pertains to the film or animation industry.  My efforts were for naught, and the only reference I found to opaquing beyond dictionary definitions for "making something opaque" came from the imdb credits page for this very film.  It seems really strange for a film to have 168 artists credited for a single job I can't find any reference to online, especially when every other credit pertaining to people who designed, laid out, animated, photographed, and cut the film totaled to 176 persons, a mere eight more for every other part of making the drawings move than whatever an opaquer does.  What's going down here?  What secrets do you hide, O The Nutcracker Prince?

I've a working theory on this, and I'd love to hear any information proving it wrong, because it speaks to some unfortunate business practices if it's right.  Of those 168 opaquers, 37 are credited in a special section for Opeongo High School, Ontario-located home to graduate Kevin Gills.  Gills served as The Nutcracker Prince's screenwriter and sole credited producer, and quite a large portion of the non-celebrity voice cast were drawn from acting contributors to his cartoon The Raccoons.  It's also worth noting how, despite the film's listings noting production by Lacewood Productions, the animation credits here name Hinton Animation Studios, a studio which fell to crippling debts mid-production and was reconstituted into Lacewood prior to release.  All this, in combination with the "opaquers" coming just after the the xerographers and matching department people, leads me to believe "opaquer" is a deliberately twisted term for "colorist," one not covered under union protections, and so an easy way for a producer operating on a tight budget to cut a few costs on his film.  Why pay a few professional colorists at scale when you can farm the operation out to a whole bunch've people for very little money, and still not pay as much as if you'd hired any union-backed folks?  You can even get a little work from the high school and not pay a dime!

Now, as I mention, this is largely speculation.  I confess I don't know too much about how many workers it typically takes to get the colors done on an animated film compared to the other departments, and it's possible the use of high schoolers could come down to Gills paying his dues and offering his old school a program for teens to get a little experience in the professional filmmaking world for school credit.  There's easily a non-sinister interpretation of events if you look for it.  However, I'm not too inclined to believe it sight unseen over thinking the practice unethical, as there are still oddities in the credits like assigning a single artist to produce the backgrounds for a solid fifteen minute chunk of film where the other background artists would only need paint roughly five-and-a-half minutes assuming roughly even distribution, or the downright odd aversion to the word "colorist" when character designers are followed immediately by "character colour design."  Something don't quite add up here to my eye, and I'd love to hear from anyone more in the know about these things than me, because I'm really quite baffled.  Is "opaquer" a common job title up in Canadian production houses, or have I really found a weird cost-cutting measure?

As one might guess from the three paragraphs focused on accreditation more than anything in the film, The Nutcracker Prince gives one reason to think it made on the cheap.  It's not particularly egregious about any of these, and looks quite nice in places for what they had, but you can TELL they weren't exactly throwing around money to spare during production.  A few of the more impressive, fluid pieces of animation get reused in the same context wholesale, faster movements trend towards choppiness and lower detail compared to the norm, and numerous actions that seem best suited to smooth execution across a single shot are broken into their individual components across multiple edits and focused on as complete actions in their own right, completely killing any illusion of naturalness.  What's more, the aforementioned fifteen-minute chunk of the film with its own background artist is so thanks to a shift in the artstyle towards something far simpler and cartoonier, which effectively means the more complex, Disney-inspired animation only requires 50 minutes finished work rather than 65.  Fine as it appears in places, including some rather impressive on-screen transformations and big gestures given the clear crunch, the crunch is still clear, and marks the film as one produced under tight conditions.

Much as I'm inclined to note its low-budget, I don't much hold this against the film.  As I keep stressing, the designs work for what they are with one or two little stand-outs (primarily the Mouse King, who looks nicely frazzled and burly), the backgrounds have a good gentle quality about them, and some of the animations had me impressed at what they could pull off on not a lot've money.  The big art style shift actually works to the film's favor in my mind, as the character designs shared across both styles read better with the thinner lines, lighter colors, and slightly lesser detailing.  Its embrace of a zanier, late 50s sketchy-mod-look-embracing Looney Tunes aesthetic also helps the film's louder, slapstickier elements feel more natural, and leaves a satisfying sensation in the mind once it's all over and done with.  I very much enjoy the dedication to showcasing sequences sure to frighten small children in the audience, as when the Mouse King is stalking Clara with a fatal wound in his chest while all the animate dolls revert back to wood and plush.  We might not have artistic triumphs here, but the artistic moderate accomplishments get the idea across on their own level all the same.

Heck, with regards to the plot and story, I appreciate how much The Nutcracker Prince draws from ETA Hoffmann.  It's pretty much the same plot points in largely the same order, with details like Clara bargaining with the Mouse King after his supposed initial defeat and the passage through the Land of Sweets left intact.  We're even free from a creepy Drosselmeyer again, which I think will only be possible through these animated adaptations - the instinct to move FAR away from "what if an eight-year old's sexual awakening by way of her godfather's tricky machinations" is absolutely the right instinct.  Where the film REALLY falls down comes with its confidence in the material.  Paul Schibli and Kevin Gillis have, if not a time-tested classic, at least a well-worn, simple template on their hands, and no good reason to tack on additional details or rearrange the structure, but they do all the same.  For example, just as Nutcracker Fantasy's Tchaikovsky quotations were rather sparse and token, here the snippets from the ballet's score come far too frequently, and are overly front-loaded.  Recognizable melody follows Christmastime staple with little time for the score to cool its heels, and before we're past fifteen minutes we've used practically everything the general public might know, thus leaving the rest little to pull out for something fresh, beyond an admitedly clever use of the final waltz across multiple emotional tones.  There's too much eagerness to prove we're doing The Nutcracker, which leaves the film a bit sonically lacking as it goes on.

When considering their lack of confidence in the novella's story and structure, the problems multiply.  The battle against the Mouse King's forces and the journey into the Land of Sweets now requires the presence of multiple new doll characters to provide further slapstick comedy and exposition about the nature of the fantasy world and its kingdom, which mark a transparent grab for inattentive children's eyes.  They're not particularly enjoyable or dignified parts, especially not Peter O'Toole's elderly, bumbling toy general, who I feel earnestly sorry he ever had to voice for any reason.  Parts must've not been very good at the time.

Our biggest issue, though, comes with the exact placement of The Hard Nut flashback segment, the prior discussed 15-minute artstyle shift.  Rather than coming between the two battles between Nutcracker and Mouse King, it is positioned at the fifteen-minute mark during the opening Christmas party, and concludes at the half-hour mark, leaving the following forty-five minutes to work through the book's first and third acts back to back.  This speaks to a distinct lack of trust in the young audience to go along with the magic of toys and mice fighting without a full explanation for why there are magic toys and talking mice that don't get along beforehand, and sets bad precedent for the film to come.  Positioning such wild silliness gives the rest of the film justification to play its comedy broad and loud even when it doesn't match the more Disney-esque artwork, and leaves us with the odd problem of characters showing up to establish their gimmick and subsequently reappearing to bring it to conclusion in the space of five minutes.  Placing the flashback where it naturally sits in Hoffmann's work, as effectively the middle act, would not only break up the action and hopefully dissuade the surrounding film from going as broad as it does, but maintain the sense of wonder and magic around that first battle, perhaps hooking an unattentive audience better than "here's some exposition but it's really silly" does.

This constitutes a LOT more words than I anticipated spilling over a minor forgotten piece of 90s children's animation based on The Nutcracker, so I feel a little bad gritting my teeth and giving it the lower rating between the two I teased in my head for most of the day.  After all, despite some shrillness in the comedy and sloppiness in the animation shouldn't entirely overwhelm a solid if unremarkable overall production.  Poor construction and lack of faith are poor construction and lack of faith, however, and I've my suspicions that the same team working under the same circumstances would've produced a stronger film if they'd stuck to what they had and didn't feel the need to, for want of a better phrase, dumb it down by tweaking the order of events and adding more trendy elements for their day.  The gentler aspects of the original story are what spoke to me most, and something trying for an early prototype version of 90s eye-rolling and purposeful tone breaking just can't get all the way over the pass line in my house.  Plus, y'know, much as one shouldn't let behind-the-scenes stuff effect their viewing unless it's concrete and doing active harm to someone, I really can't shake the notion that they weren't paying their colorists a living wage during production, and that's just shitty if it's the case.  Please, please tell me I'm off-base on this.

(It's really all down to the Mouse King - a crooked tail and a hair-trigger temper do NOT compensate for one lousy head.)

2.5/5

Sunday, December 8, 2019

Mixed Nutcrackers - Nutcracker: The Motion Picture (1986)


Is it the form, the ballet, or just me?  I ask because I really am giving pure ballet the fairest shake I can manage when watching these films predicated on capturing the dances above telling a story, but there's something in their construction which leaves me incapable of engaging to the degree I'd like, and ending up kinda bored.  With the Bolshoi production we watched to start this holiday project, such issues weren't a problem, what with it serving as my introduction to the piece and the form on stage in general, and also its being an introductory piece viewed more as context than a work unto itself.  With Nutcracker: The Motion Picture, there's just enough of the stuff I know about moviemaking and conventional narrative-based storytelling for me to get acquitted and start settling in for a proper watch, only for the film to shift into pure dance for a solid forty minute period, with very little in the way of prior narration or contextualizing shots to string it along.  My eyes glaze over, and I have a highly difficult time getting back into the swing of things.  Hence my question: is it my inexperience with the technical side of ballet that means I cannot adequately discuss and analyze large portions of the movie in the proper manner, the fact that The Nutcracker will almost always transform into exhibition rather than story when bound to Tchaikovsky's compositions, or am I simply not a ballet person?

However y'slice it, I struggle in finding an overarching perspective to use as framework for this review.  It is, then, perhaps inevitable I finally break down and rely on my old friend, Bullet Pointing The Review For The Sake Of Getting It Done And Not Sitting Round Without Writing Anything For Another Goddamned Day.  Little as I like calling their assistance, they're quite handy when invited over.  So, let's disjointedly discuss!


  • Per the Wikipedia page, director Carroll Ballard thought Godfather Drosselmeyer a creepy character without a sympathetic angle, and elected to change this by giving him more focus throughout the film.  His methods for doing this involve affording Drosselmeyer an extended montage wherein he conceptualizes and crafts all the ballet's players, sets, and props before falling asleep as a miniature stage opens on Clara's dream; filming Drosselmeyer's dancer in close-up and emphasizing his desire for Clara's attention during the Christmas party scenes; and positioning a dream version of Drosselmeyer as not only mischevious imp in the background of act 1's back half and select portions of act 2, but an actively intervening figure who serves as taskmaster over the dancers in the Land of Sweets, and seems to covet Clara's hand in marriage over the Nutcracker's.  If any of this is meant to immediately and obviously clear away the pedophilic underpinnings inherent to the work's exploring a preteen's sexual awakening by way of her creepy godfather's attentions, I don't quite see how.  No matter how much Clara's narration insists she loved Drosselmeyer as a paternal figure despite all the times he's distressed and frightened her, all we as the audience see is the frightening parts, and a dream version whose advances and machinations recast otherwise delightful dances as insidious attempts to steal Clara away from the other, far more valiant suitor.  That one can read the Nutcracker Prince as a stand-in for Clara's innocent romanticism doesn't help Drosselmeyer's case, nor does the fact that he's acted as a vaguely concerning person on all three levels of the film's reality.  I read the director saying "sympathetic," but all I see is "more overtly villainous."
  • The above said, I think Ballard's other attempts to make the movie more cinematic do function fairly well, particularly his conception of the war between toys and mice.  The Pacific Northwest Ballet's production already looks to have involved quite a lot've moving parts to achieve the classic effect of the set and its prominent Christmas tree growing around Clara, and subsequently swarming the stage with a large number of bodies dressed as toy and mice soldiers.  Ballard gives the whole thing a nice boost with some highly intricate effects work that's still grounded in the props and possibilities of a stage production, and adds in an ever-mutating Mouse King who physically grows and shifts behind the cuts to become this thirty-foot tall, six-headed (almost seven, give me SEVEN, dammit!) monster by the sequence's end.  I've no idea if Ballard or Kent Stowell and Mauriece Sendak (choreographer and production designer on the stage production) came up with the Nutcracker's dancer running round in a gigantic mascot head for the battle scene, but whoever did so had a killer idea.  It photographs really well on film, and the clumsy, leaping movements it draws from the dancer gives the Nutcracker a great deal of personality, far beyond the generic prince he becomes for act 2.  The bit with Clara and the Nutcracker crawling into the Mouse King's gigantic discarded robes also makes a good effect.
  • Despite the Christmas party sequence being shot on a set with enough coverage to establish a firm set of filmic fourth walls all round, I'd call it a good decision for Ballard to have leaned into his material's stage origins more and more as the film goes on.  The battle sequence, once through with its shifting, expanding props, takes place in a great black void somewhere between film and stage in nature, and once Clara and the Nutcracker Prince fall in love during the snowflake dance, their surroundings look far more like a theatrical production, painted backdrop and all.  When the film makes a shift to act 2, it employs the classic waving bits of cardboard water effect on a grand scale to achieve the look of Clara and the Prince sailing to a grand palace, and then stages the vast majority of the following dances on an obvious stage.  Think the way Gilliam shot the play portions of The Adventures of Baron Munchhausen, straight on with the curtains and the surrounding area clearly visible, the lights plainly just off-camera.  Doing this builds an understanding amongst the audience about diving deeper into a dreamscape whilst embracing the stage's ability to feel more believably unreal than anything too concretely cinematic, and personally gives me something to appreciate while failing to engage with the dancers.
  • In view of the above, I'm not quite sure the opening dream sequence was quite the best idea.  It takes the form of Clara tossing in fits in her sleep as blue-screened versions of herself, her younger brother, an ambiguous prince, and a mouse dance and fight their way across her mattress.  Clever, but not quite in line with how the film proceeds otherwise, and a bit of a dead end for anything other than unsettling the audience after a series of scenes that have already done the same.  The film takes its time getting into anything familiar, and while I can appreciate the impulse in trying to make this The Creepier Take on The Nutcracker, the music and dances otherwise carry on like we're working a more conventional angle, so the early and uncharacteristic nature of this dream both throws the pace off balance and contributes to a bit of (I suspect) unintended tonal dissonance.
  • I can confirm after this viewing, the Arabic dance DOES go on substantially longer than the surrounding three other cultural dances.  Still absolutely no idea why Tchaikovsky wrote it that way, and in this production its length does no favors to the bird-plumage-leotarded solo dancer's efforts in a moment when I'm already struggling to stay in the film.  The Chinese and Russian dances, however, do benefit from its length, as the already surprising and delightful bit of a squat lion-costumed man being used as a maypole by many children, and the three bounding, shirtless, gold-spackled black dancers woke me right the hell up more than I suspect the same material would've with a less lengthy lead-in.
  • Regardless of how little I know of ballet, regardless of how ill-able I am to discuss its particulars and the details of the dancers' efforts (I know absolutely nothing of positions, job names, or technique descriptions), and even knowing a filmic production like this would be able to run multiple takes and not do it all in one go, the strength and skill involved in making Clara and the Nutcracker Prince's final, triumphant dance work is stunning and admirable all the same.  Finishing it with a quick return to the bobble-headed regular Nutcracker gives me a nice last reason to smile as well.
I've no pretty bow to tie this all up with, no elegant package to box it within, but I hope the above is at least adequate reading.  Writing about Nutcracker: The Motion Picture in full would doubtlessly devolve into my whinging about how bored and unentertained I am by a medium I rarely imbide, and doing so seems so out of spirit for the project and season.  I'd far rather run the risk of making little sense by dancing round a few bullet-pointed ideas than ram through a conventionally-styled review in which I let my ignorance of how to talk about much of the film's contents dominate.  Knowing how, unfortunately, 1993's The Nutcracker is also primarily filmed ballet fills me with a bit of dread, but if we need to invite my overly-long-named friend to get through that too, so be it.  Just so long as there's something interesting to talk about.

3.5/5

Thursday, December 5, 2019

A Man For All Seasons (1966) - I trust I make myself obscure?


Letterboxd Season Challenge 2019-2020!  Theme five, part two - stage to screen adaptations!

(Chosen by Jackie!)

Let's open with some shop talk, shall we?  There's some belief amongst critics, both professionals and amateurs like myself, which posits the best example of any artistic medium is one whose most exemplary qualities best exemplify its medium's most unique qualities.  The video game that could not be any other than a video game, the painting one could not imagine as quite the same as sculpture or photograph, the film whose qualities are most vitally and enduringly filmic in nature, sort of thing.  It's a nice little maxim with quite a lot more going on beneath the surface than its simple "This is the best because it is the most" position would indicate.  A dance, for instance, might stand as an exemplary example of dance because it emphasizes the fluidity of motion possible through a highly skilled/trained performer's responses in time with music, or perhaps the strength required to achieve such fearsome or strenuous moves in so quick a time or else over such a long period, or maybe the beauty constructed by two or more in perfect, graceful sync with one another, or just maybe the elemental dance requires many in a clockwork tick-tock creation defined more by the choreographer's skill than any one dancer's choices.  What makes any dance more dance-like than the other?  Same basic problem arises when you try to concretely define what makes film film.  We can get into matters of temporal and emotional effects achieved by editing, the personalized nature of acting compared to traditional theater thanks to the camera's intimacy, the ability to visualize the impossible on a grand scale while still making room for quiet contemplation, more esoteric matters like how the picture's filmed or to what degree it is or isn't reliant on other artistic disciplines like music and whether or not the synthesis achieved by merging sight and sound is superior or inferior to their separation; but how are we to tell we're right?  And furthermore, in a time when many of film's most unique qualities at its birth (real time contrast of images, being able to move images of real things without their physical presence in the first place, animation as a discipline in general) are no longer wholly unique to it thanks to the rise of television, video games, and online video content, how exactly can we say there's any one thing that makes a movie the Most Movie?

In discussing 1966's A Man For All Seasons, I think it best to narrow the discussion's focus, and talk primarily about what makes a play so captivating, and whether or not transferring one to the silver screen without undertaking some special effort to make it more film than stagework makes a successful approach.  See, in reading reviews of the film in a search for perspectives to tackle, I found multiple pieces and posts noting how Fred Zinnemann's direction and Robert Bolt's adaptation of his own script do little to take the story of Thomas More - High Chancellor of England, author of Utopia, and noted martyr who silently refused to condone King Henry VIII's schism from the Catholic Church after so many years of opposing the Protestant Reformation under the same king, and was beheaded for it - a distinctly cinematic experience.  The film is, from this perspective, still very stagey, dependent on its words and actors to generate tension and interest in a manner more derived from the theater than the moviehouse.  It supposedly lacks a certain flair in editing, or shooting, or even acting after a fashion, which one expects from a film.  Film, after all, is not theater, and the same techniques which can thrill a live audience won't work so well on the moviegoer.  I confess to indulging in this line of thinking myself from time to time when critiquing literary or theatrical adaptations - just this last week, I put marks against The Pajama Game for lacking a more expansive manner of staging its musical numbers and confining them to soundstages in the same way its theatrical counterpart was contained by the physical limitations of the stage.  My question to you for this piece is: is it right to take the movie to task for this?

Well, yeah, depending on how you want to look at the thing.  If someone's not engaged by a film, they're not engaged by a film, and their lack of investment doesn't confer a lack of effort or thought on their part unless they give distinct and solid testimony about WHY they weren't engaged to communicate such a lack.  More likely and more fairly something in the film or else their personal taste in film that didn't click.  When the discussion surrounds fitness of adaptation from medium to medium, though, I think the question worth examining.  Certainly in my own watching I can admit A Man For All Seasons isn't quite the liveliest film from a shooting perspective.  I can't fault Ted Moore's cinematography any of his framing decisions, as he often finds interesting ways of blocking the actors to emphasize the fiery disagreements between their characters, nor can I say he totally lacks any flair beyond just filming the people, not when the repeated motif of introducing illusory power through reflections and contemplating nature when considering More before shifting to dark, brutal stonework for the corrupt institutions he stands against are so prominent features.  I CAN, however, say his deployment of these more thematically-based filming techniques are far more infrequent than one might hope, some of his extreme angle choices seem jarring against the more conventional work elsewhere, and on the whole he's not a very showy cinematographer.  He doesn't NEED to be for this story, but one more than understands the complaint about how a drama predicated on men of extreme conviction losing their tempers and communicating through grand declarations doesn't take a more daring, stylish approach to cinematography.  And though I'm going to come to his defense shortly, editor Ralph Kemplen largely strives for invisibility without too many showy cuts or unusually long takes; also fine qualities you understand, yet not what one might want from a film with this potential for explosive impact.

The problem, I think, comes in considering A Man For All Seasons as something born in the theater, and a conception of what the theater capital-I Is.  Laying aside less kind thoughts like "the people making these claims don't have much capacity to appreciate slow dramas without big displays of showmanship," I think it accurate to describe theater as the most essentially alive of the artistic forms.  So many forms of painting, sculpture, literature, etc. strive towards preserving an idea in something eternal, in a way one can find equally captivating across the decades and centuries and perhaps even millennia.  Art is referred to as the one true form of immortality, after all.  While a playwright's words and possibly stage directions will endure across performances, one potential X-factor of theater lies with the fact that it is performed by living flesh-and-blood people right before your eyes, conjuring long bygone times and ideas in the here and now, no separation beyond the unreality of production.  Those folks up there perform their craft in real time, and (one-time performances excepted) they have or will or both performed/perform again in a slightly different variation on another night.  Others have taken the mantle before and likely will again in the future.  The play is a living form of art, matched only by live music or the derived performance piece, and its ability to be something new on each repetition through hearts that beat in time with the audience's makes it Theater.

From this perspective, a play brought to film without some great transformation is a dead thing.  The performances will always take the same shape, the actors' decisions always turn out the same way, the experience never alters beyond what is achieved on final cut.  Maybe through alternate cuts in the future (cough George Lucas cough), but never in the same way a live performance can change from night to night, troupe to troupe, year to year.  Cinematic life, though highly dependent on actors in 99% of all instances, turns on the camera, the edit, the impossible, and if we only consider the essentials of what makes a movie adapted from stage a worthwhile endeavor in this way, I can fully understand why A Man For All Seasons might come across as something boring and not all that special.  Its most vitally cinematic elements stay out of the way and leave its most theatrical elements to stomp about as if they were still out on Broadway, with their warm flesh and blood replaced by cold, flat celluloid.  Doesn't make the most appealing picture.

Hence, when a mode of consideration no longer serves any use in helping us enjoy or understand a work, it is best to modify.  Although I've taken an unconscionably long time to say so, I DO still think of A Man For All Seasons the film an engaging, vibrant work.  Robert Shaw's performance as King Henry VIII might be the same every single time one turns on the film, but this does not diminish the accomplishment or visceral effect of his decision to play bombastically jolly in a way that makes his outbursts of rage at perceived slights read as active efforts to make the more steady More flinch.  Paul Scofield's lead performance as More still embodies a man of staunch religious principle whose manner and profound respect for divine law renders him a more palatable figure of spiritual conviction than many characters who hold similar beliefs (or, if we're fully honest, the historical More in all likelihood).  He still trades immensely witty, multilayered barbs with a host of character actors who can hold their own in theological tongue-spars, yet never rise far enough beyond their self-serving nature to meaningfully overcome his hardline stance on the Church's right to define law and order.  Its being an object of eternity derived from a play meant to encourage new perspectives on every performance does not, in any way, diminish the impact of Bolt's slow crawl towards realizing the hopelessness of the situation, and so redefining victory to mean standing by a single, righteous conviction above all else, nor the last minute whammy of a sudden bit of narration telling us the unhappy fates of those who persecuted More, leaving one to wonder at how evil any of them could've truly been if the vices that led to their villainy in this story ultimately produced the same fates as a man considered pious.  The delight and dread in the dialogue, More's complicated relationship with his family and fate and office, the essential vibrancy of putting this all to screen for a single production that will play the same way for all screenings across all time highlights the virtues in Bolt's work, never detracts.

I believe the film works so well because Zinnemann employs Moore and Kemplen to unobtrusive, underscoring effect.  Their work allows the film to function with minimal fuss, creating a quite lovely picture of early 16th-century England across multiple strata of life, and enables the actors to do what actors do best on film: be close and intimate with the audience.  Those moments of lost tempers, selfish, self-righteous outburst are afforded the same quiet, non-interrupting distance as bits like More sad, stately admonishment towards Richard Rich over selling his soul for Wales, and places one right there in the spittle-flecked, red-faced thick of it.  Joviality, despair, and stiff-lipped, steely-eyed conviction come across at our level, from a reality we can recognize and solid and authentic unto itself, and the ideas of what is best and right in confronting what one perceives as a moral wrong embodied by figures of great power and influence who are close confidants all the same can play out with the same immediacy as on stage.  Just as one might argue a lack of flair leaves the film staid and boring, so too can one say the lack of flair at a cinematic level allows both flair and nuance at a performative level a chance at rising to the surface, and it is this tact I take far more than the devil's advocacy I advance above.  Is it the absolute best example I've ever seen of these particular themes, or this style of performance, or this manner of presentation, or this mode of adaptation?  In honesty and earnestness, no.  But it is itself, and it is effective in captivating and teasing at my mind, and so I applaud the effort.

A thing being unchanging in form does not make it dead in experience.  The dead, for all talk of an afterlife in this film, do not experience.  It is always the living who come to A Man For All Seasons, the living who bring fresh eyes and new experiences through which to intake and interpret this one-time work.  With fresh eyes will come those who find it a less than thrilling experience, be it because they don't jive with its manner of presentation or its mode of adaptation or a simple distaste for historical drama, but there will also come new historic events to compare it against, new ways of thinking through which to view its contents, new minds who've never seen its like, or seasoned minds who've seen the like or even the film itself many times before, and yet still have wholly new experiences to color their viewing.  The great thing about film as film is difficult to define, and subject to ongoing debate - the great thing about art is its capacity to engage and inspire no matter the time or place or creed.  So, though A Man For All Seasons from 1966 is dead as theater from a strictly theatrical standpoint, it is alive and vibrant and immediate as ever as art, and so gains life as film all the same.

4/5

Tuesday, December 3, 2019

Mixed Nutcrackers - Nutcracker Fantasy (1979)


Much as I'd like to preemptively declare Sanrio's Nutcracker Fantasy the weirdest film we'll watch for this marathon, I shan't do so.  It's far too early for any statement so definitive, particularly when I've watched the trailer to Nutcracker and the Four Realms multiple times over the past week in a vain attempt to understand how and why it happened.  This said, today's film does make a fairly convincing case for the title, being a stop-motion animated work that rejiggers pieces of the ETA Hoffman story into a wholly new form inspired by The Wizard of Oz and Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, with animation courtesy of several Rankin/Bass overseas animators.  Per imdb's cast and crew page, those who worked on this film weren't CREDITED for much on their American televised work - director and editor Takeo Nakamura only has Santa Claus Is Comin' To Town listed as an animator, while puppet producer Sadao Miyamoto worked on Frosty the Snowman as an uncredited animator, Tadahito Mochinaga served as puppet technician and cinematographer on Mad Monster Party and animation supervisor on Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer, and puppet designer Ichirô Komuro went on to serve as production supervisor on several of the company's 80s productions.  Only four major names I can find amongst the credited crew in total, but considering how lax most visual presentations were about giving due credit to everyone who worked on a project beyond department heads (especially where foreign workers were concerned), and considering it shot at Mochinaga's own MOM Production studio same as the Rankin/Bass specials, I have to imagine there was more behind-the-camera experience with the form and style than one can ascertain from the on-screen accreditation.

Without the budgetary and time limitations of producing for an American televised holiday market, and with the eye and money of a booming Sanrio (backed by five years of Hello Kitty sales) on their side, Nakamura and crew show what this style of stop-motion can really do with Nutcracker Fantasy.  Sets are substantially larger and more detailed than in the familiar Christmas specials, with the lovingly dressed, two-story foyer of Clara's home and the Mouse Queen's sprawling lair standing out as particularly impressive examples.  Large crowds of characters are not only possible at a greater frequency than in Rankin/Bass' productions, they also boast a wide assortment of unique character designs, rarely resorting to mothballed old props or copycat clones.  When sets of characters with the same appearance do show up, it's justified by the presence of armies of mice and wind-up soldiers, spiced up by the addition of odd-looking generals, and more than compensated for by staging a lively, multi-plane battle with several layers of action across the horizontal and vertical plane both.  The camera's also far more lively than one typically sees with this style, crawling through the dolls and transitioning across interesting composite editing effects.  Special effects too benefit from the loftier breathing room, with far more intricate and lively integration of sparkling lights and specialized sets for trick camera moves, well beyond the overlaid gauze and animated snowflakes of Rankin/Bass' work.  I have to wonder how much Sanrio's aesthetic needs and demand for quality, or else the animators' decade-long experience with the style influenced the production, for Mad Monster Party was also produced for a theatrical release, and still suffers from the same limitations as its televised counterparts.

As an adaptation of The Nutcracker, Nutcracker Fantasy is actually a pretty fascinating reworking.  In as succinct a manner as I can manage: they've taken Godfather Drosselmeyer's story about how the Nutcracker came to be with the Mouse Queen and the cursed princess and the hard-to-crack nut, transplanted it into something inspired by the looks of the Land of Sweets without the candy themeing but with the large assortment of foreign dignitaries, expanded the conflict with an ongoing war reminiscent of the opening movement's mice/toys battle, and presented it all as a maybe dream/maybe reality situation, which nicely encapsulates every important element of Hoffmann's story.  It takes far more cues from medieval fantasy and lost girls stories, given how Clara's part for much of the story is to stand on the sidelines listening and worrying, but it's quite a clever way to rope in so much detail that's otherwise dropped from the ballet.  Some portions seem drawn from the ballet, as when the foreign wisemen are clamoring over one another to propose solutions in a manner reminiscent of their dances (just with far, FAR more nations and... ethnicities, shall we say, represented).  There's even a nod to the astronomer from Drosselmeyer's story, through the Queen of Time, whose mystical, heavenly figure of sagely advice is achieved through traditional ningyō jōruri rather than stop-motion.  S'all very neat to behold, and coupled with the aesthetics of the piece, it manages to give the film its own identity while paying clear homage to its progenitor, which mark good qualities for an adaptation.

When the film plays with its own material, it's not always quite so charming.  The beginning takes several minutes to establish a sinister Rag Man figure who seems like he'll play a major role, yet drops clean out've the narrative once the Nutcracker portions begin.  I'd suspect his loss has something to do with the English dub (the only one easily available, unfortunately) chopping out about ten minutes of footage, including two live-action dance segments, though I cannot find any substantial information on the differences.  More probably common to both versions is the court of foreign wisemen, which turns entirely on lazy stereotype humor, and mostly gets past my hackles for its clear demonstration of how varied the puppet design is in this film, as well as containing both a joke about Stalin's five year plan AND an offhand reference to Der Fuehrer's Face, both of which threw me for a loop.  The film's attempts to give Clara something to do in the climax mostly center on her wandering through a magic forest and meeting several symbolic original figures who lack much of what makes the Queen of Time interesting to watch and consider.  Most they have going being voiced by Christopher Lee, with one seeing him attempt a rather bad Irish accent.  It really must be said, while it's admirable to try and exercise Clara's emotional intelligence during this stretch, prior to the effort she has nothing to do but stand around waiting for the plot to move on, rendering her an undynamic protagonist in love with the soldier-turned-Nutcracker Franz because he looks handsome and heroic.  And, well...

I say the story's weaker when it's striking out into its own concepts, when I should really say it's at the weakest when it pulls in the one thing I'd never have imagined we'd pull from the Hoffmann story.  The reasoning behind the Mouse Queen's ire, I get snipping it out.  Clara not throwing her slipper to distract her an afford the Nutcracker a win, weird considering the ballet keeps this and makes it a more decisive action than in the story, but whatever, the sequence plays out fine on its own.  Making the secret to cracking the nut and breaking the Mouse Queen's power a pearl sword rather than someone's teeth, I guess I'm fine with it despite lessening the importance of Franz becoming a Nutcracker - these puppets don't exactly have articulate jaws.  But having Clara awake from her dream, meet her visitor Fritz, find him identical to Franz, and get married to him despite a doubtless decade-or-more age gap betwixt them?  Hoy.  Bad enough an implication when it's the 1810s and marital customs were far different than now.  Even accounting for this film's still-40 year age and differences in Japanese culture, it's still a bit of a Thing to take the story beyond a young girl's self-flattering dream world and into "They actually literally got married in real life and went to live in her fantasy kingdom, which is real, forever."  Gets one chewing one's cheek lining in discomfort, and makes some of the wholesomeness drain out've the story, not at all helped by how Clara's undying love as the only thing that can save the Nutcracker from his transformed state dropping into the story a few minutes prior with a "We've been trying to tell you this was the case all along!" line, despite this very much not being the case.  You were trying to tell her the kingdom of toys and ethnic stereotypes needed saving from a two-headed mutant mouse monster so your newfound beloved could marry someone else entirely.  Don't try to sell me a story you weren't telling in the final minutes, even if I'm in your target audience, and especially don't heavily imply a marriage between child and teenager at best, child and adult at worst.

There's other problems with Nutcracker Fantasy, mostly pertaining to the English dub - the voice acting is serviceable at best, the inclusion of Tchaikovsky snippets token, the American musical numbers not really to the standard of what their contemporaries were producing, which don't do much for me anyhow.  Taking it all into account and looking for the right ribbon with which to it it in a bow, though, I think an ultimately positive assessment is in order.  The spectacle of seeing Rankin/Bass' particular take on stop-motion design and animation given greater cinematic flair and polish than I've ever seen leaves a big impression, and the way it remixes The Nutcracker and the Mouse King into its own mini-fantasy war plot whilst homaging the source material leaves me with charm aplenty to overcome the less than stellar original material.  Just the simple fact of the Queen of Time's live puppetry amidst this collection of invisibly maneuvered figures is a memorable and impressive enough testament to the creativity on display here to get me over the "why are we implying child marriage?" hurdle.  A strong start to the holiday programming proper, and one I hope at least one non-Fantasia film can surpass before the month's out.

(Points for giving at least one mouse monarch multiple heads.  We'll see if anyone managed the full seven.)

3.5/5

Sunday, December 1, 2019

The Pajama Game (1957) - I know a dark, secluded place...


Letterboxd Season Challenge 2019-2020!  Theme five, part one - stage to screen adaptations!

I'm normally picky when it comes to older musicals.  Broadway showstoppers from the mid-century boom of plays with stories and serious issues on their minds rarely do much for me due to the focus remaining squarely upon melodrama and spectacle, while leaving their slight plots to mill about in the margins as mere excuses for the main action.  I prefer the songs to serve as primary means of storytelling, and the classic standards always treat them as entertaining diversions from the story, not really exploring any emotions or ideas beyond rapturous love, silly antics, or witheringly light tragedy through the music.  It's additionally frustrating when a work with an interesting conflict or unique setting is made to play home for yet another meet cute, fall in love, fall apart, get back together narrative with only trivial intersection with the ostensibly main conflict.  All in all, a Broadway musical from the 50s has some massive hurdles in its path if it wants to leap into my heart, and The Pajama Game hits on all the little things that annoy me about this style at a scan.

After watching George Abbott and Stanley Donen's adaptation of Abbott's hit 1954 play, I SHOULD come away with a tongue primed full've venom.  Why not?  The whole business about the pajama factory workers striking for a seven-and-a-half-cent raise serves as background dressing for the romance between Sid and Babe, which ignores the conflict for long stretches of screentime before driving a gulf between the two with a token upset, and subsequently puts no energy into their getting back together beyond "Well they're the main couple, so y'know."  Multiple musical numbers run on as little more than filler entertainment divorced from character motivations, and when they ARE character motivated, one gets situations like Babe and Sid duetting about how passionately they adore each other for two songs in a row.  As a piece of filmic work, the movie's fairly limited - despite a lively enough camera, many of the musical numbers are limited in scope and activity by the trade-in from live stage to sound stage, with only Once-A-Year-Day roaming a larger location and Hernando's Hideaway getting at all cinematic with the staging and editing.  A jealous boyfriend's murderous rage is played for laughs, the union's victory over the company is treated as overly uproarious for its eye-raising simplicity, and the overall romantic arc comes across as little more than the script asking the audience if they want these hot people to flirt some, so it SHOULD be actively hitting at every "dislike this movie" button across my entire figure.

So, why are we coming away from the experience with me metting out a four star rating?

Familiarity bias might play into it some.  I chose The Pajama Game for this theme because I'd seen a performance back in middle school, when my English teacher took the class on a field trip to watch the Tucson Community Theater's production.  As with much media I viewed at the time, I've forgotten most of the details in the intervening decades (not as big a surprise here, considering it's the only live theater show I've seen in my life, and something watched for a school project at age 12 or 13), but the standouts definitely stand out in my memory.  Snatches of Steam Heat and Hernando's Hideaway occasionally drift across my stream of conscious in free moments, and a lot of this watch was consumed by periods of "Hey!  I remember this song now!  It's great!"  That I spent an entire evening editing the Wikipedia page for the play to include details of the production from the playbill I brought home before I understood what notability constituted probably helped stick the play in my mind as something worth remembering fondly, however dimly, and primed me to think of this film as a grand ol' time regardless of elements I'd otherwise find annoying.

This doesn't quite satisfy, though.  The Pajama Game may sit in my mind as "that play I saw in middle school," but this film, divorced from my memories, still has quite a lot on offer.  Forget notions of doing something uniquely cinematic with the filmed material or using songs as a means of communicating story; the music and performances here are infectiously bouncy and varied enough to blow such preconceptions right out the door.  There's a trend towards allowing the actors' vocals to strain and fray on longer or higher notes in a way which feels highly controlled, granting moments like Doris Day's increasingly atonal response to the calls in Not At All In Love or her interplay with John Raitt on There Once Was A Man an extra degree of skin-tingling satisfaction.  The Broadway music team clearly had tons of fun tweaking at the call-and-response style of structuring, playing with swinging waltzes, rapidly shifting verbal tempos (consider the stretched out notes followed by babababababa rapidity on the verses to I'll Never Be Jealous Again, the breakneck/leisurely contrast in Small Talk, or the radically different paces on both go-arounds of Racing With The Clock), and even players dueting with themselves.  Though I'd entirely forgotten about it from the stage play, Raitt's work on the opening warning half of Hey There followed by his interplay with his recorded voice as a doubting counterpart in the second stretch was an unexpected highlight, and Day's reprise in a new, sorrowful context sold me on her status as a musical superstar better than anything in Calamity Jane.  And, of course, it helps to have big showstopper numbers like Once-A-Year-Day, which just keeps going and going and building and building without losing any of its energy or fun, and the matchlit, darkroom tango of Hernando's Hideaway, which contains the film's most well-crafted visuals.  It's an uncommonly good soundtrack all the way through, whose density only gets one charged and willing to leap from number to number with little resistance.

Beyond the music, I also think the performances help the movie along towards a higher rating quite a bit.  Looking over Wikipedia, the cuts made in adaptation rob most of the supporting cast their numbers and sideplots (Prez seems to suffer the most in this regard), but the original Broadway cast is still here minus Janis Page's Babe and Stanley Prager's Prez, and they're still giving it their all in roles they'd inhabited for three years by this point.  Carl Haney stands out in particular when the spotlight shines her way towards the end, given she's afforded the leads on both Steam Heat Hernando's Hideaway, a riotous drunken routine in the following scene, and a turn towards the climax that allows her to just wild it right the hell up with out of control screams and erratic mannerisms.  Such high-effort, high-reward mania defines the film's comedic routines, which involve large chunks of the cast getting caught in their own conflicting priorities, and blustering and shouting over one another until someone barges in to straighten the situation.  While it does not MEAN much in the way of exploring the labor conflict or romances at play, it is endearing to an extreme I cannot deny, and couples well with the same performers when they launch into song and dance.  I don't particularly need a well-defined romantic arc when Day and Raitt are giving it their all to make the all-too-short courting period seem natural before the dizzying highs of Small Talk and There Once Was A Man.  Call it emotional cheating if you will (it absolutely is), but damn if it doesn't work, and work well.

Effectively, I think the movie clips past any and all grievances I can and do raise to land at an overall positive place by doing what a Broadway entertainer does best: taking the material it has on hand, rehearsing it to perfection, and then performing with such finesse and bombast, you hardly notice or care about whatever cracks show.  Taking The Pajama Game and transplanting it to the screen with little more than some cut content and more realistic locations conducted in transit probably should break the thing in the process, and I'd be made a liar if I claimed a few elements didn't almost push me down to, at least, a 3.5.  The way Gladys and Hine-sie's little subplot resolves with them jokingly wearing prison stripe pajamas with built-in handcuffs makes me choke on my tongue a little for how bitterly 1950s it tastes, honestly.  With such strong musical and performative elements in tow, though (not to mention the production design - it's a minor thing comparatively, but I'm kinda in love with the costuming here), the film can skate right past any and all problems to convince me to go with the flow and enjoy what it has to offer.  As I've said time and again, one should strive to level with films on their level and, where possible, count a final positive experience as more important than whatever grievances come up.  In this particular case, the film's all about making good with a grievance committee, so I've an extra layer of cover for my less than professionally critical perspective than usual.

(Someone kindly tell me how Ralph Dunn wasn't made known to me as a comedic talent until last night, please.)


Lookit 'em go.

4/5

Friday, November 29, 2019

Mixed Nutcrackers - The Nutcracker at the Bolshoi Theater (1989)

(T'ain't the poster for the 1989 production.  Please roll with it nonetheless.)

Yep!  In case you thought I was at all sane and would afford the much-delayed Season Challenge stuff its proper day in the sun, we're plowing ahead with another holiday marathon, and one even larger than the last to boot!  Here on Mixed Nutcrackers, we'll take stock of multiple filmic adaptations of ETA Hoffmann's 1816 story The Nutcracker and the Mouse King and Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky's 1892 ballet The Nutcracker, and see if any of em are worth half a damn!  There's Rankin-Bass/Sanrio collaborations, Macaulay Culkin's unfortunate youth, Tom and Jerry for some reason, and inexplicable attempts to merge light children's fantasy with epic war dramas!  Plus, y'know, some nutcrackers, some sugar plums, and a whoooooooole lotta renditions of Tchaikovsky's most famous compositions.  We're already overexposed to the Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy, Dance of the Reed Flutes, and the Trepak melody thanks to their idle usage in various Christmas movies and advertisements, so catching ten works with these numbers in their proper context over the course of a month or so is sure to drive us completely and utterly mad.

Which is the whole reason of the season, is it not?  Deliberately exposing yourself and friends to potential annoyances?  Yeah.

Before we start in earnest, though, there's a little bugbear requiring our attention: I've approximately zero familiarity with any version of The Nutcracker, much less the ever-in-production ballet with such ubiquity it's been celebrated and derided alike as Baby's First Ballet.  Though I can no doubt pick up on the particulars of a story initially written and popularly performed for the five-to-ten demographic by watching the other films in this marathon, it seemed untowards to enact this whole shebang without giving the source material the time of day.  So, in this opening entry, we'll take some time to discuss Hoffmann's initial story, and a production of Tchaikovsky's famous ballet, as a matter of prelude.  For reference's sake, my choices here were a public domain audiobook of the story provided by YouTube channel FullAudiobooks, and an upload of the Bolshoi Ballet Company's 1989 production found here.  They're both worth a look if you too need a crash course on what this whole nutcracking business is about.

I think the original Hoffmann story acquits itself best in the early going, before any hint of magic beyond Godfather Drosselmeyer's mechanized marvels rears its head.  The descriptions of Marie's home in full, warm Christmas splendor and the barely contained, excited habits she and brother Fritz keep as they discover new toys and leap from fascination to fascination has about it a comfortable, friendly vibe I very much enjoy.  One feels one hardly needs more than the children's personalities, the simple conflict between Marie's greater appreciation towards a wider variety of possibilities and Fritz's stubborn attempts to act a grown soldier, to remain satisfied.  With a different turn, the story could handily end at Drosselmeyer repairing Marie's beloved Nutcracker and ending on a message about the value of kindness and appreciative thinking.  Might not've provoked such fascination in Alexander Dumas decades later, or Tchaikovsky's compositions, but it'd make a tight, nostalgic little yarn confined entirely to a little lesson on Christmas Eve values.

As there is more to The Nutcracker and the Mouse King than its opening, I find it curious how the story loses some of its charm in my eyes the more fantasy elements it introduces.  The battle between the toy soldiers and the Mouse King's forces is quite fun with how it gradually unfolds from a few strange occurrences to full-small-scale war, Drosselmeyer's story about how the Nutcracker came to be is a nice self-contained yarn though a bit long-winded and convoluted in the way old fairy tales trend towards, Marie trying to save herself from the Mouse King gets a bit repetitious, and the solid chunk dedicated towards Marie and the Nutcracker Prince travelling through the Land of Sweets loses me entirely.  It's doubtlessly down to my age at first exposure, as one hardly expects a story structured and worded with kids in mind to fully thrill an adult, but it falls into a bit of a pattern wherein we're only watching wonder after wonder pass by with minimal involvement from the principles, none of which captures my imagination too much.  Much as I'd hope to find a little childlike sparkly-eyes in any children's work, no dice here.  This proves slightly concerning, as the whole Land of Sweets sequence provides the majority of compositions in Tchaikovsky's personally selected Nutcracker Suite, as well as character and imagery fodder for much of the adaptations to follow.  Hopefully, my not finding the big "isn't this all so spellbinding and awe-inspiring" beats from Hoffmann's story too enchanting doesn't imply a lack of enjoyment in the future.

(I'll briefly remark - between Marie finding something of her godfather's countenance and character in the nutcracker, her transferring her feelings towards him onto the lifeless doll, inventing a youthful nephew for him after hearing about one in his story, and ultimately being proven right, with the young man agreeing to marry him at the ripe old age of eight in the closing pages DOES make the story vaguely uncomfortable in places.  S'mostly a sweet runaround about a girl imagining herself an adventure and romance; some parts still impart some iffy implications.)

With regards to the Bolshoi Company's production of The Nutcracker, I'll have to lay down critical perspective for the moment.  I do not know enough about ballet (or dance in general) to provide any meaningful critique of how it plays out, or designed, or performed.  Ballet when used for cinematic effect, yes; ballet on its own terms, no.  For all I know, this could be the single greatest production of The Nutcracker ever undertaken, and all others are pale imitations of its perfection, or it could be a good effort since surpassed by grander stagings.  How'm I to tell when all I can see is people dancing what I presume is very well, and a fantasia of colors and costumes playing out across the screen?

Well, putting things thusly IS a little disingenuous.  I might not have any overarching opinion on the ballet or its execution, but I CAN at least provide a few stray thoughts.  For example, I thought it impressive how a few dances employed a larger number of performers to supplement the main talent - one can take it as either additional characters joining in on the fun or fight, or an expansion of their mindset to a multitude of persons that express their thoughts and feelings in a grander manner than usual.  The decision to portray Drosselmeyer as a literal magician when presenting his gifts in the early first act communicates much the same notion about his interventions into the magical world as the story's hints towards his greater involvement without needing words, and fits the dancer's limber, spirtely movements incredibly well.  Mouse King's defeat playing more as retreat than distraction leading to a decisive final blow makes a good way to position Marie's involvement as central, though it did confuse me somewhat when the second act contained the Nutcracker Prince recounting his victory with a more traditional final duel on-stage until I thought to look at the Wikipedia summary.  It's incredibly odd how the Arabic Coffee dance in the Land of Sweets lasts longer than the Spanish Chocolate, Chinese Tea, and Russian Candy Cane dances combined - maybe something to do with the length of compositions, maybe it's that way in the original work?  So much has been rearranged since the initial, poorly-received 1892 production, so it'd come across as odd to me if that particular of timing were grandfathered in.

Naturally I'm most impressed by Natalya Arkhipova's rendition of the Sugar Plum Fairy dance.  This is going to sound so, SO mealy-mouthed and ill-educated, but there's a clockwork quality to her movements, very fast motions executed in tiny chunks with a definite pause in-between.  If one considers how those pauses vanish from sight near entirely during the faster spins, and how many mental calculations it must take to hit each point just so in such a compressed time frame even with the rigorous years of training high-end ballet demands, it becomes downright miraculous to think anyone could get it right in one go, much less night after night for a whole holiday season.  The different qualities of movement (twirls, gliding limbs, high kicks, etc) corresponding to individual instruments and conversing with one another as the various segments of the orchestral pit intersect is also quite impressive.  So concludes the extent of my ability to technically or artistically critique this ballet.

This formality out of the way, I'd say we're free to explore the nine(!) following Nutcracker-based works this Chrimbo season.  If I'm not driven to a frenzied rage by Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy's opening celesta notes by month's end, I hope y'all enjoy the marathon!

(And hey - maybe if y'all are good this year, I'll host last year's marathon here too.)

Friday, November 22, 2019

The Phantom Carriage (1921) - Lord, please let my soul come to maturity before it is reaped.


Letterboxd Season Challenge 2019-2020!  Theme four, part three - a silent horror film!

(Chosen by John!)

The last time I reviewed The Phantom Carriage, much of my discussion centered on the film's most notable supernatural element, of the last poor soul to die at the strike of New Years' midnight condemned to drive Death's carriage over nights that last thousands of years until the clock's next year-marking strike. What I identified as "the real meat of the film" occupies a rather brief paragraph before I get back to meditating on personifications of death and the overall effect of dwelling in semi-darkness through the cinematic medium.  In my defense, I was just getting started with long-form reviewing at this point, and trying to spit out my reviews soon as I finished watching to boot.  On this rewatch, I think it good and right to give said meat some proper focus, and pick apart just what makes Victor Sjöström's yarn of a wretch redeemed at great cost tick along so well.

I find it notable how the film allows us to think of David as a real bastard before we truly know him.  The opening sequences focus on the bedbound Sister Edit, dying of tuberculosis and begging those around her to summon one David Holm to her side for one final meeting before her expiration.  Scenes of her attendants debating the wisdom of this decision follow, and lead into said attendants scouring the small Swedish village for some sign of this mysterious man whose presence a woman of the faith desires so greatly - but to no avail.  Dialogue hints towards David Holm deliberately dodging those who seek his presence, cuing us into his insensitivity towards those in pain and need.  We then shift focus to listen in on a drunkard regaling his friends with strange recollections of a deceased friends' beliefs about those who die at the year's final chime, presented visually through a series of stacked flashbacks.  While Georges' story about the Phantom Carriage is depicted with the film's first instance of double exposure visuals in a manner that imparts otherworldly, deathly seriousness, and Tore Svennberg's performance within David's flashback personifies a man hollowed with fear at the prospect of such a fate befalling anyone, Sjöström plays the man's pantomimed speaking on either side of the flashbacks with a silent, dismissive cackle, even as he speaks of Georges' passing in such a way as to condemn him to the fate he so feared.  It is only after we separately understand the concept of David Holm as someone who'd actively avoid a dying woman's request and this nameless man as one who laughs at misery and suffering, a good half-an-hour into the film, that we're informed they are one and the same, effectively doubling our disgust.

When Georges arrives as the driver of the Phantom Carriage to inform David of his fate for the next year and expound on how he came to this state, the way Sjöström chooses to present and cut the tale short further exemplifies how he characterizes David as a worm who deserves his fate.  Pastoral scenes of David as a happily married family man with two beautiful children last only a brief time before Georges enters the scene and tempts David into a life of disorderly drunken abandonment, but they speak to how deep this man's faults run, especially to a modern eye.  Much as these scenes were likely intended as a rail against alcoholism and the damaging effects it wreaks upon society (especially given the original Selma Lagerlöf novel's commissioned purpose as public education about tuberculosis), I see David's quick descent as emblemizing the true immaturity of his soul.  What kind of man would turn to such vicious, nasty behavior as deliberately destroying a kindly Salvation Army woman's hard work on repairing his coat with full knowledge of the infectious risk she took in doing so after but a few rounds at the bottle and a brief stint in jail, if not one who didn't truly appreciate what he has?  True, the loss of his family is a devastating blow, but we begin this stretch of film with a David who acts the regular family man, and end it with one willing to risk others' deaths just because he's feeling particularly mean this morning, separated by only a month or two at most.  ANY minor slip would've brought him to this state, and exposed his unfitness to do more than forlornly usher souls to the beyond.

Most interesting of all to me on this watch, I find it fascinating how Sjöström continues David's damnation through the final stretch, and yet still finds reason to bring about his redemption.  When Georges forces David's spirit to stand beside Sister Edit's bed, and listen to her recollections about his life since she knew him, it paints a picture of a soul only a few shades removed from a true moral blackness.  In these passages, David deliberately coughs on people in the hopes his consumption will finish them off, professes a profound hatred for all joy in life, hunts his wife all across Sweden to the point of driving her to illness and exhaustion, reunites with her under false pretenses, deliberately risks infecting his children, and pulls what would become known in sixty years' time as A Jack Torrance with an axe - the only thing saving him from total irredeemablity is his unwillingness to take a swing at his wife once free.  Worst of all, the infection David earlier passed to Edit claims her life towards the picture's end, robbing the world of a truly selfless soul, one who looked on a wretch like David and saw someone deserving kindness and love and sacrifice, and pursued these beliefs to no avail beyond their respective deaths and the increased suffering of all who knew him.  There is practically no reason to want this man to do anything except suffer for the millennia that will pass before he must hand the carriage's reins over to another unfortunate bastard.

And yet he is redeemed.  When David Holm catches sight of his wife, in utter poverty, preparing poison to kill her children and take her own life to end their suffering, he is overcome with such agony at Georges' powerlessness over the living that he is granted a reprieve.  He wakes in the graveyard where he expired, rushes home, saves his wife, and convinces her of his true desire to reform, uttering the above-quoted prayer as the film's final word.  To my eye, David has Sister Edit's selfless kindness to thank for his salvation.  In life, her actions were met only with vindictive destruction and hateful rhetoric, which poisoned her and sank David further into his vagabond life of depravity.  In death, however, as David watches his life over again at Georges' side, seeing his cruelty with eyes free from its blinding effects, what stands out most is how far Edit went in the name of trying to help, even on so little a matter as patching the holes in his coat.  It is the sight of someone truly pure giving her all to the very end and no avail that makes David cower on the floor in an attempt to hide from the horror of his own life throughout the film's latter half, and it is the knowledge of how his living sins will continue to consume and rend apart all he held dear well past his death that gives rise to divine intervention, enabling David to truly repent, and earn a second chance at spiritual maturation before his final time of dying.

He does not deserve this.  He cost the world far, far too much in life, and stands as such a heartless, spineless bastard, I can't blame myself from nearly two years back for thinking Sjöström should've leaned into the abyss and denied David any salvation.  But at the same time, seeing a hopeless sinner realize the full implications and effects behind his careless actions and come to a second chance through purest anguish is the whole point of The Phantom Carriage.  The scenario's horror lies with its connotations beyond all else, its staying power with the impossibility of its conclusion.  Sister Edit's suffering and untimely death only possess a silver lining if we allow for the man she thought savable to the bitter end to be saved and grow beyond what he once was.  If, and only if the worst amongst us are treated as if they can one day become better is Death's terrible sting lessened, and only then does the empty void beneath the hood possess and deserve a human face.  S'a very Christian message, and one I'm happy to go along with for the sake of emotional wholeness.

4/5